Division of Oral Radiology, Department of Oral Diagnosis, Piracicaba Dental School, University of Campinas, Piracicaba, Brazil.
Eur J Dent Educ. 2020 Aug;24(3):513-517. doi: 10.1111/eje.12530. Epub 2020 May 23.
Photographs and radiographs are indispensable resources for dental education, research and dissemination of clinical cases in scientific journals. The objective of this study was to evaluate the behaviour of dentists on the use of patients' images.
Fifty-two dentists were interviewed using a semi-structured script containing open-ended questions on the use of patients' images. The answers were analysed using a qualitative-quantitative method of the discourse of the collective subject, and the distribution of the absolute and relative frequency of the answers was presented according to the central ideas obtained from the discourses.
The following central ideas on the use of patients' images were identified: (a) purpose: didactic and/or academic; (b) informed consent: verbal or absent when the patient cannot be identified; (c) discussion groups on social media contribute to learning; (d) most dentists would not appreciate and sue the author if they had their own photographs/imaging examinations posted on social media; 5. most dentists received some information on ethical regulations during dental school and state that images can be used with patient authorisation, without identification and for didactic/academic purposes.
Dentists consider the use of patients' images for didactic and scientific purposes beneficial, request informed consent to share mainly images that reveal the identity and would not appreciate if their personal images were shared without consent.
照片和 X 光片是牙科教育、研究以及在科学期刊中传播临床病例不可或缺的资源。本研究的目的是评估牙医在使用患者图像方面的行为。
对 52 名牙医进行了半结构化访谈,访谈内容包括有关使用患者图像的开放式问题。使用集体主体话语的定性-定量分析方法对答案进行分析,并根据话语中得出的中心思想呈现绝对频率和相对频率的分布。
确定了以下关于使用患者图像的中心思想:(a)目的:教学和/或学术;(b)知情同意:当无法识别患者时,口头同意或无同意;(c)社交媒体讨论组有助于学习;(d)如果他们自己的照片/成像检查被发布在社交媒体上,大多数牙医不会欣赏并起诉作者;(e)大多数牙医在牙科学院期间收到了一些关于道德法规的信息,并表示可以在获得患者同意的情况下,不进行身份识别,并出于教学/学术目的使用图像。
牙医认为使用患者图像进行教学和科学目的是有益的,要求分享主要揭示身份的图像,并表示如果未经同意分享他们的个人图像,他们不会欣赏。