Institute of Medical Psychology and Systems Neuroscience, University of Muenster, Münster, Germany.
Otto Creutzfeldt Center for Cognitive and Behavioral Neuroscience, University of Muenster, Münster, Germany.
Psychophysiology. 2020 Sep;57(9):e13585. doi: 10.1111/psyp.13585. Epub 2020 Apr 19.
The temporal dynamics of top-down voluntary and bottom-up driven emotional attention are a matter of debate. Both emotion and task-relevance have been shown to affect the early posterior negativity (EPN) and the late positive potential (LPP) during the processing of emotional pictures, whereas there are mixed findings related to interactions of emotion and task-relevance. In this preregistered study, we used Bayesian models to test this interplay between emotion and task-relevance. Participants (N = 104) were presented negative, neutral, and positive International Affective Picture System (IAPS) pictures, and block-wise were asked to respond either to negative, neutral, or positive pictures, rendering one stimulus category task-relevant and the remaining stimuli task-irrelevant. Bayesian models showed evidence for the absence of interactions between task-relevance and emotion. Furthermore, models showed parallel emotion and task effects for the EPN and late stages of the LPP. Additional interactive effects were found during an early LPP interval (400 to 600 ms), with increased LPP amplitudes when emotion was rendered task-relevant. Taken together, the results revealed distinct but parallel temporal onsets of task-relevance and emotion effects, followed by task and emotion interactions in the early LPP. Thus, based on this high-powered study employing Bayesian analysis, evidence is provided that interactions between task-relevance and emotion do not emerge before the LPP time window. These results further inform theories proposing early parallel and late interactive processes of the emotional salience of stimuli and top-down attention.
自上而下的自愿性和自下而上的驱动性情绪注意的时间动态是一个争论的问题。情绪和任务相关性都被证明会影响情绪图片处理过程中的后正成分(EPN)和晚期正成分(LPP),而与情绪和任务相关性的相互作用有关的发现则存在混合情况。在这项预先注册的研究中,我们使用贝叶斯模型来测试情绪和任务相关性之间的这种相互作用。参与者(N=104)被呈现负面、中性和积极的国际情感图片系统(IAPS)图片,并按块要求对负面、中性或积极的图片做出反应,从而使一个刺激类别与任务相关,其余刺激与任务无关。贝叶斯模型证明了任务相关性和情绪之间没有相互作用的证据。此外,模型还显示了 EPN 和 LPP 晚期的并行情绪和任务效应。在早期 LPP 间隔(400 到 600 毫秒)期间发现了额外的交互效应,当情绪变得与任务相关时,LPP 幅度增加。总之,这些结果揭示了任务相关性和情绪效应的明显但平行的时间起始,随后是早期 LPP 中的任务和情绪相互作用。因此,基于这项采用贝叶斯分析的高功率研究,提供了证据表明,在 LPP 时间窗口之前,任务相关性和情绪之间没有相互作用。这些结果进一步为提出刺激的情绪显著性和自上而下注意的早期并行和晚期交互过程的理论提供了信息。