Shrestha Roshana, Badyal Dinesh, Shrestha Anmol Purna, Shrestha Abha
Department of General Practice and Emergency Medicine, Kathmandu University School of Medical Sciences, Dhulikhel, Kavrepalanchok, Nepal.
Department of Pharmacology/Medical Education, CMCL-FAIMER Regional Institute, Ludhiana, India.
Adv Med Educ Pract. 2020 Apr 8;11:271-285. doi: 10.2147/AMEP.S246920. eCollection 2020.
Competency to perform cardiopulmonary resuscitation is essential to improve the outcome during an event of cardiac arrest. Medical internship is a "transition phase" beyond which physicians are exposed to the unpreparedness and anxiety while dealing with life-threatening conditions which need rapid actions. Experiential learning, deliberate practice and immediate feedback are the primary advantages of simulation-based medical education. In-situ simulation occurs in a real patient care environment utilizing the available resources. Our aim was to introduce in-situ simulation-based resuscitation skills training for medical interns.
This was a prospective quasi-experimental study with mixed research design conducted in the emergency department. The knowledge score questionnaire, skill-score sheet, post-simulation feedback from the interns and staff were designed, validated through experts, peer-reviewed and pilot tested. All the interns posted in the emergency department participated in the training. Appropriate statistical analyses were applied for quantitative data. Thematic analysis of the data from the open-ended questions was used to identify the themes.
Six groups of interns (n=35) participated in at least one of the 40 in-situ simulation sessions. The means of the pre- and post-simulation knowledge scores were 5.89± 2.8 SD and 11.74± 1.8 SD, respectively, and the difference was statistically significant [t (35) = 16.705, p<0.001]. The skill score had a positive correlation (Pearson correlation coefficient r=0.985, p=0.01) with the number of simulations performed in each group. The thematic analysis uncovered the themes related to the simulation methodology, reflective learning, enhancement of the non-technical skills and effective feedback. The self-reported enhancement in teamwork skills and the confidence level was significant. The feedback of the staff in the Emergency Department showed a positive attitude towards in-situ simulation.
This study demonstrated an increase in the knowledge and skills of the interns after participation in the in-situ simulation sessions. Based on the results, the study recommends that in-situ simulation-based teaching should be incorporated in the existing medical education system.
实施心肺复苏的能力对于改善心脏骤停事件中的预后至关重要。医学实习是一个“过渡阶段”,在此之后,医生在应对需要迅速行动的危及生命的情况时会面临准备不足和焦虑。体验式学习、刻意练习和即时反馈是基于模拟的医学教育的主要优势。现场模拟利用可用资源在真实的患者护理环境中进行。我们的目的是为医学实习生引入基于现场模拟的复苏技能培训。
这是一项在急诊科进行的具有混合研究设计的前瞻性准实验研究。设计了知识得分问卷、技能得分表、实习生和工作人员的模拟后反馈,经专家验证、同行评审并进行了预测试。所有派驻在急诊科的实习生都参加了培训。对定量数据进行了适当的统计分析。对开放式问题的数据进行主题分析以确定主题。
六组实习生(n = 35)参加了40次现场模拟课程中的至少一次。模拟前和模拟后的知识得分均值分别为5.89±2.8标准差和11.74±1.8标准差,差异具有统计学意义[t(35)=16.705,p<0.001]。技能得分与每组进行的模拟次数呈正相关(Pearson相关系数r = 0.985,p = 0.01)。主题分析揭示了与模拟方法、反思性学习、非技术技能的提升和有效反馈相关的主题。自我报告的团队合作技能和信心水平的提升很显著。急诊科工作人员的反馈对现场模拟持积极态度。
本研究表明,实习生在参加现场模拟课程后知识和技能有所提高。基于研究结果,该研究建议应将基于现场模拟的教学纳入现有的医学教育体系。