AlRyalat Saif Aldeen, Abukahel Areen, Elubous Khaled Ali
Department of Ophthalmology, University of Jordan, Amman, Jordan.
F1000Res. 2019 Oct 4;8:1718. doi: 10.12688/f1000research.20673.1. eCollection 2019.
Randomized controlled trials (RCTs) are situated at the top of hierarchy of evidence-based medicine, where its number and quality are important in the assessment of quality of evidence in a medical field. In this study, we aim to assess the status of RCTs in Ophthalmology. On 15 of May 2019, we performed a PubMed search for randomized controlled trials published in the field of ophthalmology using relevant filters and search terms. We categorized the results into specific topics in ophthalmology according to Medical Subject Heading (MeSH) database classification system. We used Altmetric explorer to identify journals and articles with the highest number of RCTs and highest citations. We found a total of 540,427 publications in the field of ophthalmology, of which only 11,634 (2.15%) of them were RCTs. 'Retinal diseases' was the topic with the highest number of RCTs, followed by 'glaucoma' and 'conjunctival diseases'. The trial with highest number of citations was on retinal diseases. Only around 18% of all ophthalmology RCTs are published in the top 10 ophthalmology journals, with a maximum percentage of RCTs was (5.53%) published in . RCTs in ophthalmology primarily concern the retina, glaucoma, and a few other sub-topics, with little focus on sclera, orbit, and the eyelids. Most of the high impact RCTs are published in non-ophthalmology journals.
随机对照试验(RCTs)处于循证医学证据等级体系的顶端,在医学领域证据质量评估中,其数量和质量至关重要。在本研究中,我们旨在评估眼科领域随机对照试验的现状。2019年5月15日,我们使用相关筛选条件和检索词在PubMed上检索眼科领域发表的随机对照试验。我们根据医学主题词(MeSH)数据库分类系统将结果归类为眼科的特定主题。我们使用Altmetric explorer来识别随机对照试验数量最多且被引次数最多的期刊和文章。我们发现眼科领域共有540,427篇出版物,其中只有11,634篇(2.15%)是随机对照试验。“视网膜疾病”是随机对照试验数量最多的主题,其次是“青光眼”和“结膜疾病”。被引次数最多的试验是关于视网膜疾病的。在所有眼科随机对照试验中,只有约18%发表在排名前十的眼科期刊上,发表随机对照试验比例最高的期刊为(5.53%)。眼科领域的随机对照试验主要关注视网膜、青光眼和其他一些子主题,很少关注巩膜、眼眶和眼睑。大多数高影响力的随机对照试验发表在非眼科期刊上。