New York University, New York, NY.
Montclair State University, Bloomfield, NJ.
Am J Speech Lang Pathol. 2020 May 8;29(2):873-882. doi: 10.1044/2019_AJSLP-19-00162. Epub 2020 Apr 24.
Purpose Interventions for speech disorders aim to produce changes that are not only acoustically measurable or perceptible to trained professionals but are also apparent to naive listeners. Due to challenges associated with obtaining ratings from suitably large listener samples, however, few studies currently evaluate speech interventions by this criterion. Online crowdsourcing technologies could enhance the measurement of intervention effects by making it easier to obtain real-world listeners' ratings. Method Stimuli, drawn from a published study by Sapir et al. ("Effects of intensive voice treatment (Lee Silverman Voice Treatment [LSVT]) on vowel articulation in dysarthric individuals with idiopathic Parkinson disease: Acoustic and perceptual findings" in (4), 2007), were words produced by individuals who received intensive treatment (LSVT LOUD) for hypokinetic dysarthria secondary to Parkinson's disease. Thirty-six online naive listeners heard randomly ordered pairs of words elicited pre- and posttreatment and reported which they perceived as "more clearly articulated." Results Mixed-effects logistic regression indicated that words elicited posttreatment were significantly more likely to be rated "more clear." Across individuals, acoustically measured magnitude of change was significantly correlated with pre-post difference in listener ratings. Conclusions These results partly replicate the findings of Sapir et al. (2007) and demonstrate that their acoustically measured changes are detectable by everyday listeners. This supports the viability of using crowdsourcing to obtain more functionally relevant measures of change in clinical speech samples. Supplemental Material https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.12170112.
言语障碍干预旨在产生不仅在声学上可测量或可被专业人员感知,而且也能被非专业听众明显察觉的变化。然而,由于从足够大的听众样本中获得评分存在挑战,目前很少有研究通过这一标准来评估言语干预措施的效果。在线众包技术可以通过更容易地获得真实听众的评分来增强干预效果的测量。
刺激材料取自 Sapir 等人发表的一项研究(Sapir 等人,“强化嗓音治疗(Lee Silverman 嗓音治疗 [LSVT])对特发性帕金森病运动障碍性构音障碍患者的元音发音的影响:声学和感知学发现”,《语言语音学杂志》,2007 年),由接受强化治疗(LSVT LOUD)的个体产生的词,这些个体患有帕金森病引起的运动障碍性构音障碍。36 名在线非专业听众随机听到治疗前后诱发的单词对,并报告他们认为哪些单词“发音更清晰”。
混合效应逻辑回归表明,治疗后诱发的单词更有可能被评为“发音更清晰”。个体之间,可测量的变化量与听众评分的前后差异呈显著正相关。
这些结果部分复制了 Sapir 等人(2007 年)的发现,并表明他们在声学上测量的变化可以被日常听众察觉。这支持了使用众包技术来获得更具临床意义的语音样本变化的可行性。