School of Social Work and Criminology, Université Laval, Quebec City, Quebec, Canada.
Centre interdisciplinaire de recherche en réadaptation et intégration sociale (CIRRIS), Quebec City, Quebec, Canada.
Gerontologist. 2020 Aug 14;60(6):1126-1136. doi: 10.1093/geront/gnaa011.
While older adults' social participation has attracted sustained attention, the realities faced by seniors with impairments in this area are still understudied. Social representations are formed from socially constructed opinions regarding a given object and have four functions (knowledge, identity, orientation, justification). The purpose of this article is to document the social representations that exist within seniors' organizations regarding participation by older people with impairments.
In this mixed-methods study, an exploratory sequential design was applied. First, a qualitative phase involved meetings with five focus groups to explore how participants would manage difficult situations in which the inclusion of an older person with impairments must be addressed. Second, a quantitative phase consisted of a questionnaire administered to 86 respondents to examine the components of social representations about the participation of older people with impairments.
Results show that, although research participants acknowledge that all seniors have the right to participate, this right confronts a collective identity infused with aging model that demands a youthful, "un-disabled" appearance and activities. In terms of the orientation function, making participation a reality is seen as relying on the efforts of people with impairments, but when there is a failure of inclusiveness, the reasons offered to justify it concern the resources available, rather than possible prejudices.
Interpretation of the results leads to recommendations for both implementing an inclusion philosophy and practices in seniors' organizations and revisiting the view of impairment in old age as otherness.
尽管老年人的社会参与一直受到关注,但在这方面有障碍的老年人所面临的现实仍然研究不足。社会表征是由对给定对象的社会建构意见形成的,具有四个功能(知识、身份、定位、证明)。本文旨在记录老年人组织中关于有障碍的老年人参与的社会表征。
在这项混合方法研究中,采用了探索性顺序设计。首先,进行了一个定性阶段,包括与五个焦点小组的会议,以探讨参与者如何处理必须解决包括有障碍的老年人在内的困难情况。其次,进行了一个定量阶段,即向 86 名受访者发放问卷,以检查关于有障碍的老年人参与的社会表征的组成部分。
结果表明,尽管研究参与者承认所有老年人都有参与的权利,但这一权利与老龄化模式的集体认同相冲突,这种模式要求具有年轻、“无残疾”的外表和活动。在定位功能方面,使参与成为现实被视为依赖于有障碍的人的努力,但当包容性失败时,为证明其合理性提供的理由涉及到可用资源,而不是可能存在的偏见。
对结果的解释提出了在老年人组织中实施包容哲学和实践的建议,并重新审视了将残疾视为老年人的他者的观点。