Mangano F G, Admakin O, Bonacina M, Biaggini F, Farronato D, Lerner H
Department of Prevention and Communal Dentistry, Sechenov First Moscow State Medical University, 119992 Moscow, Russia.
Ars and Technology, 24039 Sotto il Monte Giovanni XXIII (BG), Italy.
Eur J Prosthodont Restor Dent. 2020 May 28;28(2):75-85. doi: 10.1922/EJPRD_2050Mangano11.
To compare the accuracy of 6 desktop 3D printers in dentistry.
A parallelepiped (PP) with known geometry and holes of different diameters was designed and printed with 6 desktop 3D printers (Sheraprint 40®; Solflex 350®; Form 2®; MoonRay D75®; Vida HD®; XFAB 2000®). For each printer, 9 PPs were printed with proprietary materials; these PPs were not cured and underwent dimensional analysis by optical microscopy and precision probing. A file representative of a dentate model (DM) was also printed with the aforementioned printers. For each printer, 3 DMs were printed with the proprietary materials. These DMs were cured and after 1 month, scanned with a desktop scanner and superimposed on the virtual reference model, to investigate trueness.
Dimensional analysis by optical microscopy and precision probing highlighted the reliability of the 3D printed models; errors were compatible with clinical use. However, both linear and diameter measurements revealed statistically significant differences between the machines. The trueness of the DMs 1 month after printing was low, suggesting that they underwent dimensional contraction over time, albeit with differences between the printers.
The 3D printed models showed acceptable accuracy, although statistically significant differences were found among them.
比较6款牙科桌面式3D打印机的准确性。
设计了一个具有已知几何形状和不同直径孔洞的平行六面体(PP),并用6款桌面式3D打印机(Sheraprint 40®;Solflex 350®;Form 2®;MoonRay D75®;Vida HD®;XFAB 2000®)进行打印。对于每台打印机,使用专用材料打印9个PP;这些PP未固化,并通过光学显微镜和精密探测进行尺寸分析。还使用上述打印机打印了一个代表有牙颌模型(DM)的文件。对于每台打印机,使用专用材料打印3个DM。这些DM进行固化,1个月后,用桌面扫描仪进行扫描,并叠加在虚拟参考模型上,以研究准确性。
通过光学显微镜和精密探测进行的尺寸分析突出了3D打印模型的可靠性;误差与临床使用相符。然而,线性测量和直径测量均显示各机器之间存在统计学上的显著差异。打印1个月后DM的准确性较低,表明它们随时间发生了尺寸收缩,尽管各打印机之间存在差异。
3D打印模型显示出可接受的准确性,尽管它们之间存在统计学上的显著差异。