Division of Rheumatology, Duke Molecular Physiology Institute, Duke University School of Medicine, 300 North Duke St, Box 104775, Durham, NC, 27701, USA.
Rheumatology, Biomarkers and Research, Nordic Bioscience, Herlev, Denmark.
Calcif Tissue Int. 2021 Sep;109(3):329-338. doi: 10.1007/s00223-020-00701-7. Epub 2020 May 4.
The ultimate hope of researchers and patients is a pathway to development of treatments for osteoarthritis to modify the disease process in addition to the symptoms. However, development of disease modifying drugs requires objective endpoints such as measures of joint structure, joint tissue homeostasis and/or joint survival-measures such as provided by imaging biomarkers, molecular biomarkers and joint replacement frequency, respectively. Although biomarkers supporting investigational drug use and drug approval include surrogate endpoints that may not necessarily reflect or directly correlate with the clinical outcome of interest, a formal biomarker qualification process currently exists that is a rigorous three stage process that yields biomarker approvals (or denials) for specific contexts of use. From a cost perspective, biochemical biomarkers are the 'ones to beat'; however, even well-validated biomarkers may not cross the translation gaps for eventual use in healthcare unless they offer an advantage in terms of cost per quality adjusted life year. This review summarizes the case FOR and AGAINST biomarkers in drug development and highlights the current data for a subset of biomarkers in the osteoarthritis research field informing on cartilage homeostasis, joint inflammation and altered subchondral bone remodeling.
研究人员和患者的最终希望是找到一种治疗骨关节炎的方法,除了缓解症状外,还能改变疾病进程。然而,开发疾病修正药物需要客观的终点,如关节结构、关节组织平衡和/或关节存活率的测量——分别由成像生物标志物、分子生物标志物和关节置换频率提供。尽管支持研究性药物使用和药物批准的生物标志物包括替代终点,这些终点不一定反映或直接相关感兴趣的临床结果,但目前存在一个正式的生物标志物资格认证过程,这是一个严格的三阶段过程,可在特定使用情况下批准(或拒绝)生物标志物。从成本角度来看,生化生物标志物是“最具挑战性的”;然而,即使是经过充分验证的生物标志物,如果它们在每质量调整生命年的成本方面没有优势,也可能无法跨越最终用于医疗保健的转化差距。这篇综述总结了生物标志物在药物开发中的正反两面,并强调了当前骨关节炎研究领域中一组生物标志物的现有数据,这些数据反映了软骨平衡、关节炎症和骨重塑改变。