Department of Medical Epidemiology and Biostatistics, Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm, Sweden.
National Perinatal Epidemiology and Biostatistics Unit, Centre for Big Data Research in Health and School of Women and Children's Health, University of New South Wales, Sydney, Australia.
Sci Rep. 2020 May 6;10(1):7661. doi: 10.1038/s41598-020-64633-w.
Asthma may negatively affect children's school performance, such as grades and exam results. Results from previous studies have shown varying results and may have suffered from confounding and other biases. We used a Swedish population-based cohort of 570,595 children with data on asthma (including severity and control) in Grades 7-8 and 9, school performance from Grade 9 (grade point sum, non-eligibility for upper secondary school and national test results) and measured confounders from national registers. We used sibling comparisons to account for unmeasured familial factors. Children with asthma and severe asthma performed slightly better in school than children without asthma when adjusting for measured confounders, but the associations were attenuated in sibling comparisons. In contrast, children with uncontrolled asthma performed slightly worse (e.g. Grade 9: β = -9.9; 95% CI -12.8 to -7.0; Cohen's d = 0.16). This association remained for uncontrolled asthma in Grade 9 in sibling comparisons (Grade 9: β = -7.7 points; 95% CI -12.6 to -2.6; Cohen's d = 0.12), but not for Grades 7-8. The attenuation of estimates when controlling for familial factors using sibling comparisons suggests that the differences were due to familial factors, rather than being causal. The remaining associations in sibling comparisons between uncontrolled asthma in Grade 9 and school performance are consistent with a causal association.
哮喘可能会对儿童的学业表现产生负面影响,例如成绩和考试成绩。以往研究的结果显示结果不一,可能受到混杂因素和其他偏倚的影响。我们使用了瑞典基于人群的 570595 名儿童队列,这些儿童在 7-8 年级和 9 年级有哮喘(包括严重程度和控制情况)的数据、9 年级的学业成绩(总分数、无法升读高中和国家考试成绩),并从国家登记册中测量了混杂因素。我们使用兄弟姐妹比较来解释未测量的家族因素。在调整了已测量的混杂因素后,患有哮喘和重度哮喘的儿童在学校的表现略优于没有哮喘的儿童,但在兄弟姐妹比较中,这种关联减弱了。相比之下,未得到控制的哮喘儿童的表现略差(例如,9 年级:β=−9.9;95%CI:−12.8 至−7.0;Cohen's d=0.16)。在兄弟姐妹比较中,这种关联在 9 年级的未控制哮喘中仍然存在(9 年级:β=−7.7 分;95%CI:−12.6 至−2.6;Cohen's d=0.12),但在 7-8 年级则不存在。当使用兄弟姐妹比较控制家族因素时,估计值的减弱表明这些差异是由家族因素引起的,而不是因果关系。在 9 年级未控制哮喘与学业成绩之间的兄弟姐妹比较中,剩余的关联与因果关系一致。