Plaze M, Attali D, Petit A-C, Blatzer M, Simon-Loriere E, Vinckier F, Cachia A, Chrétien F, Gaillard R
GHU Paris psychiatrie et neurosciences, site Sainte-Anne, service hospitalo-universitaire, pôle hospitalo-universitaire Paris 15, Paris, France; Université de Paris, Paris, France.
GHU Paris psychiatrie et neurosciences, site Sainte-Anne, service hospitalo-universitaire, pôle hospitalo-universitaire Paris 15, Paris, France; Université de Paris, Paris, France; Physics for medicine Paris, Inserm, ESPCI Paris, CNRS, PSL Research university, université Paris Diderot, Sorbonne Paris Cite, Paris, France.
Encephale. 2020 Jun;46(3S):S35-S39. doi: 10.1016/j.encep.2020.04.010. Epub 2020 Apr 29.
The ongoing COVID-19 pandemic comprises a total of more than 2,350,000 cases and 160,000 deaths. The interest in anti-coronavirus drug development has been limited so far and effective methods to prevent or treat coronavirus infections in humans are still lacking. Urgent action is needed to fight this fatal coronavirus infection by reducing the number of infected people along with the infection contagiousness and severity. Since the beginning of the COVID-19 outbreak several weeks ago, we observe in GHU PARIS Psychiatrie & Neurosciences (Sainte-Anne hospital, Paris, France) a lower prevalence of symptomatic and severe forms of COVID-19 infections in psychiatric patients (∼4%) compared to health care professionals (∼14%). Similar observations have been noted in other psychiatric units in France and abroad. Our hypothesis is that psychiatric patients could be protected from severe forms of COVID-19 by their psychotropic treatments. Chlorpromazine (CPZ) is a phenothiazine derivative widely used in clinical routine in the treatment of acute and chronic psychoses. This first antipsychotic medication has been discovered in 1952 by Jean Delay and Pierre Deniker at Sainte-Anne hospital. In addition, to its antipsychotic effects, several in vitro studies have also demonstrated a CPZ antiviral activity via the inhibition of clathrin-mediated endocytosis. Recently, independent studies revealed that CPZ is an anti-MERS-CoV and an anti-SARS-CoV-1 drug. In comparison to other antiviral drugs, the main advantages of CPZ lie in its biodistribution: (i) preclinical and clinical studies have reported a high CPZ concentration in the lungs (20-200 times higher than in plasma), which is critical because of the respiratory tropism of SARS-CoV-2; (ii) CPZ is highly concentrated in saliva (30-100 times higher than in plasma) and could therefore reduce the contagiousness of COVID-19; (iii) CPZ can cross the blood-brain barrier and could therefore prevent the neurological forms of COVID-19.
Our hypothesis is that CPZ could decrease the unfavorable evolution of COVID-19 infection in oxygen-requiring patients without the need for intensive care, but also reduce the contagiousness of SARS-CoV-2. At this end, we designed a pilot, phase III, multicenter, single blind, randomized controlled clinical trial. Efficacy of CPZ will be assessed according to clinical, biological and radiological criteria. The main objective is to demonstrate a shorter time to response (TTR) to treatment in the CPZ+standard-of-care (CPZ+SOC) group, compared to the SOC group. Response to treatment is defined by a reduction of at least one level of severity on the WHO-Ordinal Scale for Clinical Improvement (WHO-OSCI). The secondary objectives are to demonstrate in the CPZ+SOC group, compared to the SOC group: (A) superior clinical improvement; (B) a greater decrease in the biological markers of viral attack by SARS-CoV-2 (PCR, viral load); (C) a greater decrease in inflammatory markers (e.g. CRP and lymphopenia); (D) a greater decrease in parenchymal involvement (chest CT) on the seventh day post-randomization; (E) to define the optimal dosage of CPZ and its tolerance; (F) to evaluate the biological parameters of response to treatment, in particular the involvement of inflammatory cytokines. Patient recruitment along with the main and secondary objectives are in line with WHO 2020 COVID-19 guidelines.
This repositioning of CPZ as an anti-SARS-CoV-2 drug offers an alternative and rapid strategy to alleviate the virus propagation and the infection severity and lethality. This CPZ repositioning strategy also avoids numerous developmental and experimental steps and can save precious time to rapidly establish an anti-COVID-19 therapy with well-known, limited and easy to manage side effects. Indeed, CPZ is an FDA-approved drug with an excellent tolerance profile, prescribed for around 70 years in psychiatry but also in clinical routine in nausea and vomiting of pregnancy, in advanced cancer and also to treat headaches in various neurological conditions. The broad spectrum of CPZ treatment - including antipsychotic, anxiolytic, antiemetic, antiviral, immunomodulatory effects along with inhibition of clathrin-mediated endocytosis and modulation of blood-brain barrier - is in line with the historical French commercial name for CPZ, i.e. LARGACTIL, chosen as a reference to its "LARGe ACTion" properties. The discovery of those CPZ properties, as for many other molecules in psychiatry, is both the result of serendipity and careful clinical observations. Using this approach, the field of mental illness could provide innovative therapeutic approaches to fight SARS-CoV-2.
目前的新冠疫情已导致超过235万例病例和16万例死亡。到目前为止,抗冠状病毒药物研发的进展有限,仍缺乏预防或治疗人类冠状病毒感染的有效方法。因此,迫切需要采取行动,通过减少感染人数以及感染的传染性和严重性来对抗这种致命的冠状病毒感染。自新冠疫情在几周前爆发以来,我们在法国巴黎精神科与神经科学GHU(圣安妮医院)观察到,与医护人员(约14%)相比,精神科患者中出现症状性和严重形式新冠感染的比例较低(约4%)。法国国内外的其他精神科病房也有类似观察结果。我们的假设是,精神科患者可能因其精神药物治疗而免受严重形式的新冠感染。氯丙嗪(CPZ)是一种吩噻嗪衍生物,在临床常规中广泛用于治疗急慢性精神病。这种第一种抗精神病药物于1952年由让·德莱和皮埃尔·德尼克在圣安妮医院发现。此外,除了其抗精神病作用外,多项体外研究还通过抑制网格蛋白介导的内吞作用证明了CPZ的抗病毒活性。最近,独立研究表明CPZ是一种抗中东呼吸综合征冠状病毒(MERS-CoV)和抗严重急性呼吸综合征冠状病毒1(SARS-CoV-1)的药物。与其他抗病毒药物相比,CPZ的主要优势在于其生物分布:(i)临床前和临床研究报告肺部CPZ浓度较高(比血浆中高20 - 200倍),这一点至关重要,因为新冠病毒具有呼吸道嗜性;(ii)CPZ在唾液中高度浓缩(比血浆中高30 - 100倍),因此可以降低新冠的传染性;(iii)CPZ可以穿过血脑屏障,因此可以预防新冠的神经症状形式。
我们的假设是,CPZ可以降低需要吸氧但无需重症监护的患者中新冠感染的不良进展,还可以降低新冠病毒的传染性。为此,我们设计了一项试点、III期、多中心、单盲、随机对照临床试验。CPZ的疗效将根据临床、生物学和放射学标准进行评估。主要目标是证明与标准治疗(SOC)组相比,CPZ + 标准治疗(CPZ + SOC)组的治疗反应时间(TTR)更短。治疗反应定义为在世界卫生组织临床改善序贯量表(WHO-OSCI)上严重程度至少降低一级。次要目标是证明与SOC组相比,CPZ + SOC组:(A)临床改善更优;(B)新冠病毒攻击的生物学标志物(PCR、病毒载量)下降幅度更大;(C)炎症标志物(如CRP和淋巴细胞减少)下降幅度更大;(D)随机分组后第7天实质受累(胸部CT)下降幅度更大;(E)确定CPZ的最佳剂量及其耐受性;(F)评估治疗反应的生物学参数,特别是炎症细胞因子的参与情况。患者招募以及主要和次要目标均符合世界卫生组织2020年新冠指南。
将CPZ重新定位为抗新冠病毒药物提供了一种替代且快速的策略,以减轻病毒传播以及感染的严重性和致死率。这种CPZ重新定位策略还避免了众多研发和实验步骤,可以节省宝贵时间,以便迅速建立一种具有已知、有限且易于管理副作用的抗新冠治疗方法。事实上,CPZ是一种已获美国食品药品监督管理局批准的药物,耐受性良好,在精神病学领域已使用约70年,在临床常规中还用于治疗妊娠恶心和呕吐、晚期癌症以及各种神经系统疾病引起的头痛。CPZ广泛的治疗谱——包括抗精神病、抗焦虑、止吐、抗病毒、免疫调节作用以及抑制网格蛋白介导的内吞作用和调节血脑屏障——与CPZ在法国的历史商品名LARGACTIL相符,该名称是因其“广泛作用”特性而选定的。与精神病学中的许多其他分子一样,CPZ这些特性的发现既是偶然的结果,也是仔细临床观察的结果。采用这种方法,精神疾病领域可以为对抗新冠病毒提供创新的治疗方法。