Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON.
Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON.
J Obstet Gynaecol Can. 2020 Sep;42(9):1111-1115. doi: 10.1016/j.jogc.2020.02.113. Epub 2020 May 8.
To develop and implement a trial of labour after cesarean delivery (TOLAC) bundle-a group of interventions aimed at decreasing cesarean delivery (CD) for women who have had a prior CD (Robson group 5).
A TOLAC bundle was developed that included: (1) educational rounds for health care providers, (2) a physician-patient TOLAC discussion aid, and (3) patient-centred educational resources. A before-and-after study design was employed. A one-year chart review determined baseline CD rates in Robson group 5 patients at a tertiary care academic centre. Following this, from February 1, 2018 until May 31, 2019, each bundle intervention was sequentially introduced every four to six months and modified based on provider feedback. Obstetricians were provided with their individual CD rates using an audit-and-feedback approach prior to the introduction of the next intervention.
The baseline CD rate for Robson group 5 patients was 71% (175/247 eligible patients). Following the introduction of the bundle, the CD rate decreased to 61% (131/214 eligible patients). This was a 10% decrease in the CD rate (P = 0.029). A significant increase in rate of induction was noted, from 5% pre-intervention to 11% post-intervention (p = 0.017). There were no significant decreases in the rate of vaginal birth after CD or increases in the rates of uterine rupture or NICU admission.
A TOLAC bundle, consisting of provider education, a TOLAC discussion aid, and patient resources, combined with audit and feedback, decreased CD for Robson group 5 patients.
制定并实施剖宫产术后经阴道分娩(TOLAC)方案包——一组旨在减少既往行剖宫产术(罗伯逊分组 5)妇女再次剖宫产术(CD)的干预措施。
制定了 TOLAC 方案包,其中包括:(1)医疗保健提供者教育轮次;(2)医患 TOLAC 讨论辅助工具;(3)以患者为中心的教育资源。采用前后对照研究设计。在三级学术医疗中心,对一年的病历回顾确定了罗伯逊分组 5 患者的基线 CD 率。在此之后,从 2018 年 2 月 1 日至 2019 年 5 月 31 日,每四个月至六个月依次引入一个方案包干预措施,并根据提供者的反馈进行修改。在引入下一个干预措施之前,通过审计和反馈为产科医生提供其个人 CD 率。
罗伯逊分组 5 患者的基线 CD 率为 71%(175/247 例符合条件的患者)。引入方案包后,CD 率下降至 61%(131/214 例符合条件的患者)。CD 率降低了 10%(P=0.029)。注意到诱导分娩率显著增加,从干预前的 5%增加到干预后的 11%(p=0.017)。CD 后阴道分娩率无显著下降,子宫破裂或新生儿重症监护病房(NICU)入院率无显著增加。
TOLAC 方案包由提供者教育、TOLAC 讨论辅助工具和患者资源组成,结合审计和反馈,降低了罗伯逊分组 5 患者的 CD 率。