Department of Health and Welfare, Ostfold University College, Halden, Norway.
Department of Anesthesiology, Ostfold Hospital Trust, Grålum, Norway.
PLoS One. 2020 May 12;15(5):e0232984. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0232984. eCollection 2020.
Cardiac arrest is rare in pregnancy, and up-to date competence can be difficult to assess and maintain. The objective of this study was to develop and validate a questionnaire to assess healthcare personnel experiences, self-assessed competence and perception of role and resposibility related to cardiac arrest and cardio-pulmonary resuscitation (CPR) in pregnancy.
The study had a cross-sectional design, developing and validating a questionnaire: the Competence in cardiac arrest and CPR in pregnancy (ComCA-P). Development and validation of the ComCA-P was conducted in three stages: 1) Literature review and expert group panel inputs, 2) a pilot study and 3) a cross-sectional questionnaire study. In stage one, the ComCA-P was developed over several iterations between the researchers, including inputs from an expert group panel consisting of highly competent professionals (n = 11). In stage two, the questionnaire was piloted in a group of healthcare personnel with relevant competence (n = 16). The ComCA-P was then used in a baseline study including healthcare personnel potentially involved in CPR in pregnancy (n = 527) in six hospital wards. Based on these data, internal consistency, intra-class correlations, and confirmatory factor analysis were utilized to validate the questionnaire.
The expert group and pilot study participants evaluated the appropriateness, relevance and accuracy to be high. Formulation of the items was considered appropriate, with no difficulties identified related to content- or face validity. Cronbach's alpha was 0.8 on the thematic area self-assessment, and 0.73 on the theoretical knowledge area of the ComCA-P. On both the self-assessed competence items and the teoretical knowledge items, Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin was 0.8. Moreover, the Bertletts' test of sphericity was greater than the critical value for chi-square, and significant (p < .0001).
Findings indicate that the ComCA-P is a valid questionnaire that can be used to assess healthcare personnel competence in cardiac arrest and resuscitation in pregnancy.
心脏骤停在妊娠中很少见,要评估和保持最新的能力可能很困难。本研究的目的是开发和验证一种评估医疗保健人员在妊娠中经历、自我评估能力以及对与心脏骤停和心肺复苏(CPR)相关的角色和责任的感知的问卷。
该研究采用横断面设计,开发和验证了一种问卷:妊娠中心脏骤停和 CPR 能力(ComCA-P)。ComCA-P 的开发和验证分为三个阶段:1)文献回顾和专家小组小组意见,2)试点研究和 3)横断面问卷研究。在第一阶段,研究人员之间进行了多次迭代,包括来自由高度熟练的专业人员组成的专家小组小组(n = 11)的意见。在第二阶段,该问卷在具有相关能力的医疗保健人员小组(n = 16)中进行了试点。然后,在包括可能参与妊娠 CPR 的医疗保健人员的基线研究(n = 527)中使用了 ComCA-P,该研究在六个病房进行。基于这些数据,使用内部一致性、组内相关系数和验证性因子分析来验证问卷。
专家小组和试点研究参与者评估了适当性、相关性和准确性,认为非常高。项目的制定被认为是适当的,没有发现与内容或表面有效性相关的困难。ComCA-P 的主题领域自我评估的 Cronbach's alpha 为 0.8,理论知识领域的 Cronbach's alpha 为 0.73。在自我评估能力项目和理论知识项目上,Kaiser-Meyer-Olkin 均为 0.8。此外,Bertletts 球形检验的 chi-square 值大于临界值,且具有统计学意义(p <.0001)。
研究结果表明,ComCA-P 是一种有效的问卷,可以用于评估医疗保健人员在妊娠中处理心脏骤停和复苏的能力。