Department of Agricultural and Resource Economics, North Carolina State University, Raleigh, NC, USA.
Pest Manag Sci. 2020 Nov;76(11):3527-3536. doi: 10.1002/ps.5912. Epub 2020 Jun 11.
Over the last few decades, the use of Farmer Field Schools (FFS) have been considered one of the best approaches to disseminate integrated pest management (IPM) practices that aim to reduce reliance on and misuse of chemical pest control methods in agriculture. However, the published empirical literature has been decidedly mixed in terms of the effectiveness of the IPM-FFS approach to improve economic outcomes in the short-term (e.g. reduce chemical use, improve profits), and the potential for scaling-up and IPM dissemination in the medium-term. This article briefly explores the empirical IPM-FFS literature and draws implications for future research directions that can potentially enhance IPM knowledge diffusion methods (including IPM-FFS) and increase the economic impact of IPM techniques in low-income countries. We find that promising research directions to improve understanding of IPM dissemination and IPM impacts will need to involve: (i) interdisciplinary long-run studies using rigorous evaluation methods; (ii) in-depth assessments of spillover effects; (iii) careful examination of IPM and IPM-FFS impact heterogeneity; (iv) evaluation of novel IPM packages with herbicide- and genetics-centered components; (v) piloting and impact assessments of alternative IPM knowledge diffusion structures; and (vi) piloting and impact analysis of IPM dissemination and learning programs with private sector involvement. © 2020 Society of Chemical Industry.
在过去的几十年里,农民田间学校 (FFS) 的使用被认为是传播综合虫害管理 (IPM) 实践的最佳方法之一,这些实践旨在减少对农业中化学防治方法的依赖和滥用。然而,已发表的实证文献在 IPM-FFS 方法在短期(例如减少化学使用、提高利润)内提高经济成果的有效性以及在中期扩大规模和推广 IPM 方面存在明显的分歧。本文简要探讨了 IPM-FFS 的实证文献,并对未来的研究方向提出了启示,这些研究方向可能增强 IPM 知识传播方法(包括 IPM-FFS)并提高 IPM 技术在低收入国家的经济影响。我们发现,要提高对 IPM 传播和 IPM 影响的理解,有希望的研究方向将需要涉及:(i)使用严格评估方法的跨学科长期研究;(ii)深入评估溢出效应;(iii)仔细检查 IPM 和 IPM-FFS 影响的异质性;(iv)评估具有除草剂和基因为中心的成分的新型 IPM 方案;(v)试验和评估替代 IPM 知识传播结构的影响;以及(vi)试验和分析具有私营部门参与的 IPM 传播和学习计划的影响。 © 2020 化学工业协会。