Sassi C, Picapedra A, Álvarez-Vaz R, Martins Schmidt C, Ulbricht V, Daruge Júnior E, Francesquini Júnior L
Department of Forensic Dentistry, Piracicaba Dental School, State University of Campinas, São Paulo, Brazil.
Department of Public Health, Dental School, Federal University of Rio Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre, Brazil.
J Forensic Odontostomatol. 2020 May 15;38(1):8-17.
Sex determination, which is based on the existence of dimorphism between specimens of the same species, plays an important role in the process of human identification. In the absence of pelvic elements, the skull appears to be the best sex indicator, and can also be submitted to quantitative or metric assessments. Eleven measurements were taken for this study, four in the sagittal plane and seven in the horizontal, in two groups of 186 skulls each, with 101 from males and 85 from females for those of the sagittal plane, and 100 and 86, respectively, for those concerning the horizontal, of subjects aged between 18 and 94 years at the time of death. The sample belongs to the Osteological and Tomographic Biobank Professor Doctor Eduardo Daruge of the Piracicaba Dental School of the University of Campinas. The aim of this research was to establish a reliable method to determine sex and elaborate mathematical prototypes capable of assisting in investigation or identification activities, in a preliminary study. Of the measures implemented (Lambda-Nasion, Lambda-Rhinion, Lambda-Nasospinale, Rhinion-Nasospinale, Zygomaxillare-Zygomaxillare, Lambda-Incisive Foramen, Lambda-Right Zygomaxillare, Lambda-Left Zygomaxillare, Basion-Incisive Foramen, Basion-Right Zygomaxillare and Basion-Left Zygomaxillare), only the Lambda-Nasospinale and Rhinion-Nasospinale in the sagittal plane, and the Zygomaxillare-Zygomaxillare and Lambda-Incisive Foramen in the horizontal plane, were significantly dimorphic. Two predictive mathematical models of sex were conceived for each pair of them: one of logistic regression and another of conditional inference trees, displaying accuracy rates of 78.5% and 77.42%, and of 68.28% and 72.04%, respectively. The authors concluded that there is the possibility to apply the aforementioned data in forensic anthropology as an auxiliary tool in investigation or identification tasks.
基于同一物种标本间存在的二态性进行的性别鉴定,在人类身份识别过程中发挥着重要作用。在没有骨盆元素的情况下,头骨似乎是最佳的性别指标,并且还可以进行定量或测量评估。本研究进行了11项测量,矢状面4项,水平面7项,分为两组,每组186个头骨。矢状面测量中,男性101个,女性85个;水平面测量中,男性100个,女性86个,死者年龄在18至94岁之间。该样本属于坎皮纳斯大学皮拉西卡巴牙科学院的骨学和断层扫描生物样本库教授爱德华多·达鲁热医生。本研究的目的是建立一种可靠的性别鉴定方法,并在初步研究中精心设计能够协助调查或识别活动的数学模型。在所实施的测量中(枕点-鼻根点、枕点-鼻下点、枕点-鼻棘点、鼻下点-鼻棘点、左右颧骨点间距、枕点-切牙孔、枕点-右侧颧骨点、枕点-左侧颧骨点、颅底点-切牙孔、颅底点-右侧颧骨点和颅底点-左侧颧骨点),只有矢状面的枕点-鼻棘点和鼻下点-鼻棘点,以及水平面的左右颧骨点间距和枕点-切牙孔存在显著的二态性。针对每一对显著二态性的测量指标,构建了两个性别预测数学模型:一个是逻辑回归模型,另一个是条件推断树模型,准确率分别为78.5%和77.42%,以及68.28%和72.04%。作者得出结论,有可能将上述数据应用于法医人类学,作为调查或识别任务中的辅助工具。