Pearce-Walker Jennifer I, Troup Daniel J, Ives Rebecca, Ikner Luisa A, Rose Joan B, Kennedy Melissa A, Verhougstraete Marc P
Am J Vet Res. 2020 Jun;81(6):506-513. doi: 10.2460/ajvr.81.6.506.
To determine whether exposure to UV germicidal irradiation (UVGI) reduces concentrations of viable aerosolized microorganisms (attenuated strains of common veterinary pathogens) in a simulated heating, ventilation, and air conditioning (HVAC) system.
42 air samples seeded with bacteriophage MS2 or attenuated strains of , feline calicivirus, feline herpesvirus-1, canine parvovirus, or canine distemper virus (6/microorganism) or with no microorganisms added (6).
A simulated HVAC unit was built that included a nebulizer to aerosolize microorganisms suspended in phosphate-buffered water, a fan to produce airflow, 2 UVGI bulb systems, and an impinger for air sampling. Ten-minute trials (3 with UVGI, 3 without UVGI, and 1 negative control) were conducted for each microorganism. Impingers collected microorganisms into phosphate-buffered water for subsequent quantification with culture-based assays. Results for samples yielding no target microorganisms were recorded as the assay's lower limit of detection. Statistical analysis was not performed.
The UVGI treatment resulted in subjectively lower concentrations of viable MS2, , and canine distemper virus (arithmetic mean ± SD log microorganism reduction, 2.57 ± 0.47, ≥ 3.45 ± 0.24, and ≥ 1.50 ± 0.25, respectively) collected from air. Feline herpesvirus-1 was detected in only 1 sample without and no samples with UVGI treatment. Feline calicivirus and canine parvovirus were not detectable in any collected samples.
Results for some surrogates of veterinary pathogens suggested a potential benefit to supplementing manual disinfection practices with UVGI-based air cleaning systems in animal care environments. Further research is needed to investigate the utility of UVGI in operating HVAC systems.
确定暴露于紫外线杀菌辐照(UVGI)是否会降低模拟供暖、通风与空调(HVAC)系统中可存活的气溶胶化微生物(常见兽医病原体的减毒株)的浓度。
42份空气样本,其中接种了噬菌体MS2或猫杯状病毒、猫疱疹病毒-1、犬细小病毒或犬瘟热病毒的减毒株(每种微生物6份样本),或未添加微生物(6份样本)。
构建了一个模拟HVAC装置,其中包括一个用于雾化悬浮在磷酸盐缓冲水中的微生物的雾化器、一个产生气流的风扇、2个UVGI灯泡系统以及一个用于空气采样的冲击器。对每种微生物进行了10分钟的试验(3次使用UVGI,3次不使用UVGI,以及1次阴性对照)。冲击器将微生物收集到磷酸盐缓冲水中,随后通过基于培养的测定法进行定量。未产生目标微生物的样本结果记录为该测定法的检测下限。未进行统计分析。
UVGI处理使从空气中收集到的可存活的MS2、[此处原文缺失一种微生物名称]和犬瘟热病毒的浓度在主观上降低(算术平均值±标准差,微生物减少对数分别为2.57±0.47、≥3.45±0.24和≥1.50±0.25)。仅在1份未进行UVGI处理的样本中检测到猫疱疹病毒-1,而在进行UVGI处理的样本中未检测到。在任何收集的样本中均未检测到猫杯状病毒和犬细小病毒。
一些兽医病原体替代物的结果表明,在动物护理环境中,用基于UVGI的空气清洁系统补充手动消毒做法可能有益。需要进一步研究以调查UVGI在运行HVAC系统中的效用。