Galdiz Juan B, Gómez Alba, Rodriguez Diego, Guell Rosa, Cebollero Pilar, Hueto Javier, Cejudo Pilar, Ortega Francisco, Sayago Itxaso, Chic Susana, Iscar Marta, Amado Carlos, Rodríguez Trigo Gemma, Cosio Borja G, Bustamante Victor, Pijoan José Ignacio
Respiratory Department, Hospital Universitario Cruces, Osakidetza, Biocruces Bizkaia Health Research Institute, CibeRes, Barakaldo, Spain.
Unitat Rehabilitació Cardio-Respiratoria, Hospital Universitari Vall d'Hebron, Barcelona, Spain.
Arch Bronconeumol (Engl Ed). 2021 Mar;57(3):195-204. doi: 10.1016/j.arbres.2020.03.034. Epub 2020 May 19.
There is uncertainty regarding efficacy of telehealth-based approaches in COPD patients for sustaining benefits achieved with intensive pulmonary rehabilitation (PR).
To determine whether a maintenance pulmonary telerehabilitation (TelePR) programme, after intensive initial PR, is superior to usual care in sustaining over time benefits achieved by intensive PR.
A multicentre open-label pragmatic parallel-group randomized clinical trial was conducted. Two groups were created at completion of an 8-week intensive outpatient hospital PR programme. Intervention group (IG) patients were given appropriate training equipment and instructed to perform three weekly training sessions and send performance data through an app to a web-based platform. Patients in the control group (CG) were advised to exercise regularly (usual care).
Ninety-four patients (46 IG, 48 CG) were randomized. The analysis of covariance showed non-significant improvements in 6-min walk distance [19.9m (95% CI -4.1/+43.8)] and Chronic Respiratory Disease Questionnaire - Emotion score [0.4 points (0-0.8)] in the IG. Secondary linear mixed models showed improvements in the IG in Short Form-36 mental component summary [9.7, (4.0-15.4)] and Chronic Respiratory Disease Questionnaire - Emotion [0.5, (0.2-0.9)] scores, but there was no association between compliance and outcomes. Acute exacerbations were associated with a marginally significant decrease in 6-minute walk distance of 15.8m (-32.3/0.8) in linear models.
The TelePR maintenance strategy was both feasible and safe but failed to show superiority over usual care, despite improvements in some HRQoL domains. Acute exacerbations may have an important negative influence on long-term physical function. CLINICALTRIALS.
NCT03247933.
基于远程医疗的方法对慢性阻塞性肺疾病(COPD)患者维持强化肺康复(PR)所取得的益处的疗效尚不确定。
确定在初始强化PR后,维持性肺远程康复(TelePR)计划在维持强化PR所取得的益处方面是否优于常规护理。
进行了一项多中心开放标签实用平行组随机临床试验。在为期8周的强化门诊医院PR计划完成后,将患者分为两组。干预组(IG)患者被给予适当的训练设备,并被指示每周进行三次训练,并通过应用程序将训练数据发送到基于网络的平台。对照组(CG)患者被建议定期锻炼(常规护理)。
94例患者(46例IG,48例CG)被随机分组。协方差分析显示,IG组的6分钟步行距离[19.9米(95%CI -4.1/+43.8)]和慢性呼吸系统疾病问卷-情绪评分[0.4分(0-0.8)]无显著改善。二次线性混合模型显示,IG组在简明健康状况调查简表-心理成分总结[9.7,(4.0-15.4)]和慢性呼吸系统疾病问卷-情绪[0.5,(0.2-0.9)]评分方面有所改善,但依从性与结局之间无关联。线性模型显示,急性加重与6分钟步行距离略有显著下降15.8米(-32.3/0.8)相关。
TelePR维持策略既可行又安全,但尽管在一些健康相关生活质量领域有所改善,但未能显示出优于常规护理的优势。急性加重可能对长期身体功能有重要负面影响。临床试验。
NCT03247933。