Deeney Megan, Harris-Fry Helen
Faculty of Epidemiology and Population Health, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, London, UK.
Matern Child Nutr. 2020 Oct;16(4):e13018. doi: 10.1111/mcn.13018. Epub 2020 May 26.
Optimising child feeding behaviours could improve child health in Guatemala, Honduras and El Salvador, where undernutrition rates remain high. However, the design of interventions to improve child feeding behaviours is limited by piecemeal, theoretically underdeveloped evidence on factors that may influence these behaviours. Between July 2018 and January 2020, we systematically searched Cochrane, Medline, EMBASE, Global Health and LILACS databases, grey literature websites and reference lists, for evidence of region-specific causes of child feeding behaviours and the effectiveness of related interventions and policies. The Behaviour Change Wheel was used as a framework to synthesise and map the resulting literature. We identified 2,905 records and included 68 relevant studies of mixed quality, published between 1964 and 2019. Most (n = 50) were quantitative, 15 were qualitative and three used mixed methods. A total of 39 studies described causes of child feeding behaviour; 29 evaluated interventions or policies. Frequently cited barriers to breastfeeding included mothers' beliefs and perceptions of colostrum and breast milk sufficiency; fears around child illness; and familial and societal pressures, particularly from paternal grandmothers. Child diets were influenced by similar beliefs and mothers' lack of money, time and control over household finances and decisions. Interventions (n = 22) primarily provided foods or supplements with education, resulting in mixed effects on breastfeeding and child diets. Policy evaluations (n = 7) showed positive and null effects on child feeding practices. We conclude that interventions should address context-specific barriers to optimal feeding behaviours, use behaviour change theory to apply appropriate techniques and evaluate impact using robust research methods.
优化儿童喂养行为可以改善危地马拉、洪都拉斯和萨尔瓦多儿童的健康状况,这些国家的营养不良率仍然很高。然而,改善儿童喂养行为的干预措施设计受到限制,因为关于可能影响这些行为的因素的证据零散且理论上不够完善。在2018年7月至2020年1月期间,我们系统地检索了考克兰图书馆、医学索引数据库、循证医学数据库、全球健康数据库和拉丁美洲及加勒比卫生科学数据库、灰色文献网站以及参考文献列表,以寻找关于儿童喂养行为特定区域原因以及相关干预措施和政策有效性的证据。行为改变轮被用作一个框架来综合和梳理所得文献。我们识别出2905条记录,并纳入了68项质量参差不齐的相关研究,这些研究发表于1964年至2019年之间。大多数(n = 50)是定量研究,15项是定性研究,3项采用了混合方法。共有39项研究描述了儿童喂养行为的原因;29项评估了干预措施或政策。经常被提及的母乳喂养障碍包括母亲对初乳和母乳充足性的信念和认知;对儿童疾病的恐惧;以及家庭和社会压力,特别是来自祖母的压力。儿童饮食受到类似信念以及母亲缺钱、时间以及对家庭财务和决策缺乏控制权的影响。干预措施(n = 22)主要是提供食物或补充剂并进行教育,对母乳喂养和儿童饮食产生了不同的影响。政策评估(n = 7)对儿童喂养行为产生了积极和无效果的结果。我们得出结论,干预措施应解决影响最佳喂养行为的特定背景障碍,运用行为改变理论应用适当的技术,并使用可靠的研究方法评估影响。