Keenan Heather T, Albertine Kurt H, Upperman Jeffrey S, Dean J Michael
Department of Pediatrics, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, UT.
Department of Surgery, Keck School of Medicine of the University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA.
Pediatr Crit Care Med. 2020 Jul;21(7):672-678. doi: 10.1097/PCC.0000000000002348.
To assess the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development's Pediatric Critical Care Trauma Scientist Development Program national K12 program.
Mixed-methods study.
Pediatric Critical Care Trauma Scientist Development Program participants from 2005 to 2018.
Past participants in the Pediatric Critical Care Trauma Scientist Development Program, including those who received funding (scholars), those who did not receive funding (applicants), and those who participated as diversity fellows.
None.
Thirty-four past scholars, participants, and fellows in the Pediatric Critical Care Trauma Scientist Development were interviewed, including 19 women (56%) and 15 men (44%) via Skype. Interviews were audio recorded and transcribed, with permission. Codes were developed, using qualitative methods, that included the following: Community Building and Mentorship, Career and Research Development, and Tensions and Growth Opportunities. Quantitative data about physician-scholar grant success were retrieved from the National Institutes of Health system to search for funded grants, RePORT, physician-scholar curriculum vitae, and university websites. Since inception of the program, 46 scholars have been appointed. Scholars are equally split between women and men. Four members of the total cohort (9%) are from under-represented minority groups in medicine. Among the total past 46 participants, 72% of those who completed the K12 achieved an National Institutes of Health K-award and 36% of those not on K-level funding achieved at least one Research Program Grant-level award. All scholars, except one, remain academically active, as noted by recent publications in the peer reviewed literature; scholars from 2005 to 2013 are progressing in their careers, with 60% promoted to associate or full professor.
The Pediatric Critical Care Trauma Scientist Development Program is reaching its programmatic goals of buildin g a community of scientists in pediatric critical care and trauma surgery as shown by the qualitative analysis. Key challenges include increasing the diversity of applicants, encouraging applicants who are not funded, increasing the rate of K- to R-conversion, and preserving National Institute of Child Health and Human Development Program priorities for national K12 programs and individual K-awards.
评估美国国立儿童健康与人类发展研究所的儿科重症监护创伤科学家发展计划全国K12项目。
混合方法研究。
2005年至2018年参与儿科重症监护创伤科学家发展计划的人员。
儿科重症监护创伤科学家发展计划的过往参与者,包括获得资助者(学者)、未获得资助者(申请者)以及作为多元化研究员参与的人员。
无。
对34名儿科重症监护创伤科学家发展计划的过往学者、参与者和研究员进行了访谈,其中19名女性(56%)和15名男性(44%)通过Skype进行访谈。经许可,访谈进行了录音和转录。采用定性方法制定了编码,包括以下方面:社区建设与指导、职业与研究发展、矛盾与成长机会。从美国国立卫生研究院系统中检索了关于医师学者资助成功的定量数据,以查找获得资助的项目、RePORT、医师学者简历和大学网站。自该项目启动以来,已任命了46名学者。学者中男女比例相等。总队列中有4名成员(9%)来自医学领域代表性不足的少数群体。在过去46名参与者中,完成K12项目的人员中有72%获得了美国国立卫生研究院的K类奖项,未获得K级资助的人员中有36%至少获得了一项研究项目资助级别的奖项。除一人外,所有学者在学术上仍很活跃,同行评审文献中的近期出版物表明了这一点;2005年至2013年的学者职业发展顺利,60%晋升为副教授或正教授。
定性分析表明,儿科重症监护创伤科学家发展计划正在实现其在儿科重症监护和创伤外科领域建立科学家群体的计划目标。主要挑战包括增加申请者的多样性、鼓励未获得资助的申请者、提高从K类到R类的转化率,以及保持美国国立儿童健康与人类发展研究所项目对全国K12项目和个人K类奖项的优先考虑。