Speech Sciences Program, Centre for Rehabilitation and Special Needs, Faculty of Health Sciences, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia; Speech Pathology Program, School of Health Sciences, Universiti Sains Malaysia, Kelantan, Malaysia.
Speech Sciences Program, Centre for Rehabilitation and Special Needs, Faculty of Health Sciences, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.
J Voice. 2022 Jan;36(1):106-112. doi: 10.1016/j.jvoice.2020.04.027. Epub 2020 May 24.
Ideally, an analysis method for laryngeal high-speed videoendoscopy (LHSV) based on the glottal area waveforms (GAW) requires images of a complete view of the glottis to ensure findings that are representatives of the vibratory behaviors of the whole vocal folds. However, in practice, the preferred images may not be obtained at all times. Often, the only available images that a clinician has to work with consist of a partial view of the glottis. This study aims to examine the effects of using images of a partial view of the glottis (ie, posterior-middle, anterior-middle, or middle) on the LHSV-based measures (ie, fundamental frequency (F0, frequency perturbation (jitter, amplitude perturbation (shimmer, open quotient (OQ, and Nyquist plot). The participants consisted of 9 young normophonic females. The procedures involved LHSV recording of the vibration of the vocal folds. The images of the complete view of the glottis were analyzed to obtain the LHSV-based measures. The same images were used to simulate the images of partial views of the glottis by changing the outline of the region of interest to include only either the posterior-middle, anterior-middle, or middle parts of the glottis. The LHSV-based measures from the images of the partial views were then compared to those with the complete view . The results showed that all LHSV-based measures from the images of the posterior-middle view were similar to those of the complete view. However, only the F0, jitter, and shimmer from the images of the anterior-middle and middle views were similar to those of the complete view. Lower OQ and different Nyquist plots than those of the complete view were generated by the images of the anterior-middle and middle views. In conclusion, all LHSV-based measures from the images of the posterior-middle view of the glottis, and only the F0, jitter and shimmer from the images of the anterior-middle and middle views of the glottis reflect the vibratory behaviors of the whole vocal folds. The same conclusion could not be applied to the OQ and Nyquist plots of the images of the anterior-middle and middle views of the glottis. A possible effect of the presence or absence of a posterior glottal gap on the findings warrants further confirmation.
理想情况下,基于声门区面积波(GAW)的喉高速视频内镜(LHSV)分析方法需要完整的声门图像,以确保发现结果能够代表整个声带的振动行为。然而,在实践中,并非总能获得理想的图像。通常,临床医生唯一可用于工作的图像仅包含声门的部分视图。本研究旨在检查使用声门部分视图(即后-中、前-中或中)的图像对基于 LHSV 的测量值(即基频(F0)、频率微扰(抖动)、幅度微扰(渐细)、开放商(OQ)和奈奎斯特图)的影响。参与者包括 9 名年轻的正常发音女性。该程序涉及声带振动的 LHSV 记录。对完整声门图像进行分析以获得基于 LHSV 的测量值。使用相同的图像通过改变感兴趣区域的轮廓来仅包括声门的后-中、前-中或中部部分,从而模拟声门的部分视图图像。然后将来自部分视图图像的基于 LHSV 的测量值与完整视图进行比较。结果表明,来自后-中视图图像的所有基于 LHSV 的测量值均与完整视图相似。然而,只有来自前-中视图和中视图的 F0、抖动和渐细与完整视图相似。来自前-中视图和中视图的图像生成的 OQ 较低,并且奈奎斯特图与完整视图不同。总之,来自声门后-中视图的所有基于 LHSV 的测量值,以及仅来自声门前-中视图和中视图的 F0、抖动和渐细,都反映了整个声带的振动行为。来自声门前-中视图和中视图的图像的 OQ 和奈奎斯特图则不能应用相同的结论。后声门间隙的存在或不存在对发现结果的可能影响需要进一步确认。