Badiye Ashish, Kathane Prachi, Krishan Kewal
Government Institute of Forensic Science, Nagpur, Maharashtra, India
School of Forensic Science and Risk Management, Raksha Shakti University
Gait analysis refers to the systematic study of human movement during walking. In the forensic setting, gait analysis, or forensic gait comparison, involves assessing a suspect’s gait patterns and features and comparing them with gait evidence obtained from a crime scene for purposes of criminal or personal identification. In practice, this technique functions as a supportive contributor to the broader identification process rather than a standalone method, because the idea that an individual’s gait is uniquely identifiable has not yet been fully validated scientifically. The forensic gait analysis's general source or evidence comprises the series of footprints found at the crime scene and the closed-circuit television camera (CCTV) footage. Footprints are evidence found at the crime scene. Footprints can be recovered in the form of bare prints, shoeprints, and a series of imprints. Footprints can be encountered in several types of cases and crime scenes, such as house break-ins and theft, robbery, sexual assaults, hit and run, shoplifting, homicides, and kidnapping. The science of footprints and gait analysis is a part of an emerging sub-discipline of forensic science known as forensic podiatry. Forensic podiatry is "the application of podiatric knowledge and experience in forensic investigations. It shows the association of an individual with a scene of a crime, or to answer any other legal question concerned with the foot or footwear that requires knowledge of the functioning foot." The principles and knowledge of forensic podiatry help the investigating officers and crime scene investigators when they are involved with the foot, footwear, and/or gait-related evidence at the crime scene. This knowledge can further establish the suspect's physical or biological profile for individualization and identification. Meanwhile, an investigating officer is always on the lookout for evidence linking the suspect to the crime scene. In recent times, gait analysis has emerged as an important parameter for personal identification in forensic examinations. The advent of CCTV cameras and other surveillance technologies has generated interest in forensic gait analysis and its possible use in human individualization. In 1839, in London, gait analysis was introduced in court in the case of Thomas Jackson; a witness identified him due to his bowed left leg and limp. However, for the very first time, the forensic gait analysis was used as a means of admissible evidence/scientific evidence in the Old Bailey Central Criminal Court, London, UK, in the case of R vs Saunders by the UK based forensic podiatrist, Dr. Haydn Kelly, although, the method of forensic gait analysis remains questionable as far as the reliability and accuracy are concerned. The topic discusses forensic gait analysis methods, factors affecting human gait, its forensic applications, and its accuracy, reliability, and admissibility in court.
步态分析被称为“对人类运动的系统研究”。法医步态分析或法医步态比较被定义为“对个人/嫌疑人的步态模式和特征进行评估,并将这些特征与犯罪现场证据进行比较,以进行刑事/个人身份识别”。换句话说,法医步态分析可被定义为身份识别过程的一个辅助因素,而非一种身份识别方法,因为尚未完全科学地证明一个人的步态具有个体独特性。法医步态分析的一般来源或证据包括在犯罪现场发现的一系列脚印以及闭路电视(CCTV)录像。脚印是在犯罪现场遇到的证据之一。脚印可以以裸脚印、鞋印以及一系列压痕的形式被获取。脚印可出现在多种类型的案件和犯罪现场,如入室盗窃(HBT)、抢劫、性侵、肇事逃逸、盗窃商品、杀人、绑架等。脚印和步态分析科学是法医学一个新兴子学科——法医足病学的一部分。法医足病学是“将足病学知识和经验应用于法医调查。它显示个人与犯罪现场的关联,或回答任何其他与脚或鞋类有关的法律问题,而这需要对足部功能有所了解”。当调查人员和犯罪现场调查人员处理犯罪现场与脚、鞋类和/或步态相关的证据时,法医足病学的原理和知识会对他们有所帮助。这些知识可以进一步确定嫌疑人的身体或生物学特征以实现个体化和身份识别。与此同时,调查人员一直在寻找能将嫌疑人与犯罪现场联系起来的证据。近年来,步态分析已成为法医检查中有助于个人身份识别的一个重要参数。闭路电视摄像机和其他监控手段的出现引发了对法医步态分析实践与研究以及其在人类个体化方面可能用途的兴趣。1839年,在伦敦,步态分析在托马斯·杰克逊案中进入法庭;由于他左腿弯曲且走路一瘸一拐,证人认出了他。然而,英国法医足病医生海顿·凯利博士首次在英国伦敦老贝利中央刑事法庭的R诉桑德斯案中,将法医步态分析用作可采信证据/科学证据的一种手段,不过,就可靠性和准确性而言,法医步态分析方法仍存在疑问。本文讨论法医步态分析方法、影响人类步态的因素、其法医应用以及在法庭上的准确性、可靠性和可采信性。