Ando Yuichi, Ueshima Hiroki, Watanabe Taeko, Tamiya Nanako
Health Services Research and Development Center, University of Tsukuba.
Institute of Global Medical and Sports Science Japan, Inc.
Nihon Koshu Eisei Zasshi. 2020;67(5):311-318. doi: 10.11236/jph.67.5_311.
Objectives Comprehensive community sports clubs (CCSCs), of which more than 3,500 exist in Japan, have the potential to contribute to healthy aging in older adults, but their effect on this population has not, thus far, been well explored. This study aimed to investigate the current environment affecting seniors at Japanese CCSCs and to examine issues identified by the analysis.Methods Data were collected from the FY 2016 Survey Results on Comprehensive Community Sports Clubs, conducted by the Japan Sports Agency. A total of 2,444 clubs were divided equally into four groups after calculating the proportion of senior members (ages 60 and over) per total number of members in each club. The groups were then ranked from lowest to highest according to proportion of senior members: Groups A, B, C and D. Additionally, the 2,444 clubs were classified into six regions according to location. Group designation (A to D) and regional classification were used as independent variables. The dependent variables were categorized as follows: basic information (e.g. total number of members), crisis management and accident prevention measures (13 specific items in total), and each club's compliance with legal obligations.Results Study results revealed that Group D, containing the highest proportion of senior members, had fewer total members, lower monthly membership fees, lower annual club income, less annual club budget apportioned to each member, and fewer instructors than other groups. Regarding crisis management and accident prevention measures, Group D had lower completion rates on 6 items (health certificate submissions, liability insurance enrollment, safety workshop implementation, heatstroke prevention, liaison with healthcare professionals, and AED availability). Group D also showed a lower rate of compliance with legal obligations than other groups. In comparisons between the six regions, the median proportion of senior members was found to be highest in Chugoku-Shikoku and lowest in Chubu, although each median ranged from only 20% to 30%. Regarding crisis management and accident prevention measures, clubs in Kanto region had the highest completion rates for 10 items, whereas clubs in Kinki region had the lowest completion rates for 8 items.Conclusion The CCSCs with higher proportions of senior members had smaller budgets, fewer members and staff, and delayed implementation of crisis management and accident prevention measures. Regional disparities were also observed both in club scale and management of medical and safety issues. Although our study identified several shortcomings in this area, medical and safety management implementation is an important consideration for CCSCs with high proportions of senior members, as these members are at higher risk for disease and frailty. Affected CCSCs and relevant authorities should therefore acknowledge and address this issue cooperatively.
目标 在日本,有超过3500家综合社区体育俱乐部(CCSC),它们有潜力促进老年人健康老龄化,但迄今为止,其对这一人群的影响尚未得到充分研究。本研究旨在调查影响日本CCSC中老年人的当前环境,并审视分析中发现的问题。
方法 数据收集自日本体育机构开展的2016财年综合社区体育俱乐部调查结果。在计算每个俱乐部老年成员(60岁及以上)占成员总数的比例后,将总共2444家俱乐部平均分为四组。然后根据老年成员比例从低到高对这些组进行排序:A组、B组、C组和D组。此外,根据地理位置将2444家俱乐部分为六个地区。组的指定(A至D)和地区分类用作自变量。因变量分类如下:基本信息(如成员总数)、危机管理和事故预防措施(总共13个具体项目)以及每个俱乐部对法律义务的遵守情况。
结果 研究结果显示,老年成员比例最高的D组,其成员总数较少,月会员费较低,年度俱乐部收入较低,分配给每个成员的年度俱乐部预算较少,且教练数量比其他组少。在危机管理和事故预防措施方面,D组在6个项目(健康证明提交、责任保险登记、安全研讨会实施、中暑预防、与医疗专业人员的联络以及自动体外除颤器的可用性)上的完成率较低。D组对法律义务的遵守率也低于其他组。在六个地区的比较中,发现老年成员的中位数比例在中国四国地区最高,在中部地区最低,尽管每个中位数仅在20%至30%之间。在危机管理和事故预防措施方面,关东地区的俱乐部在10个项目上的完成率最高,而近畿地区的俱乐部在8个项目上的完成率最低。
结论 老年成员比例较高的CCSC预算较小,成员和工作人员较少,危机管理和事故预防措施的实施也较滞后。在俱乐部规模以及医疗和安全问题管理方面也存在地区差异。尽管我们的研究发现了该领域的几个不足之处,但对于老年成员比例较高的CCSC来说,医疗和安全管理的实施是一个重要考虑因素,因为这些成员患病和身体虚弱的风险较高。因此,受影响的CCSC和相关当局应共同认识并解决这个问题。