Liu Huan, Gao Jing-Hua, Xie Yan-Ming, Li Yuan-Yuan, Zhang Ling, Li Sheng-Hua, Xu Zu-Jian, Huang Feng, Li Gang, Wang Yong-Yan
Institute of Basic Research in Clinical Medicine, China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences Beijing 100700, China.
Wangjing Hospital, China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences Beijing 100102, China.
Zhongguo Zhong Yao Za Zhi. 2020 May;45(10):2300-2303. doi: 10.19540/j.cnki.cjcmm.20200218.501.
Shujin Jianyao Pills is a Chinese patent medicine, with anti-inflammation, analgesic and anti-osteoporotic effects. Based on a questionnaire investigation of clinicians and a systematic review of study literatures on Shujin Jianyao Pills, the international clinical practice guidelines development method was adopted to analyze the optimal available evidences and expert experiences in the "evidence-based, consensus-based and experience-based" principles. Expert consensus on Shujin Jianyao Pills in clinical practice(GS/CACM267-2019) was developed by more than 30 multidisciplinary experts nationwide with the aim to guide and standardize the rational use of Shujin Jianyao Pills among clinicians and improve the clinical efficacy and safety. The expert consensus adopted the internationally recognized recommendation criteria for classification of evidence--GRADE. Expert consensus was formed by the nominal group method. Six main considerations were quality of evidence, curative effect, safety, economical efficiency, patient acceptability and other factors. If there were sufficient evidences, a "recommendation" was given, and GRADE grid voting rule was adopted. If there wasn't sufficient evidence, a "consensus opinion" was formed, and the majority counting rule. According to the indication, usage and do-sage, drug use for special population and safety of Shujin Jianyao Pills, one recommendation and nine consensus opinions were put forward. By means of expert meetings and correspondence, a nationwide consultations and peer reviews were conducted. This consensus is applicable to clinicians in hospitals and grass-roots health services, and provides guidance and reference for the rational use of Shujin Jianyao Pills.
舒筋健腰丸是一种中成药,具有抗炎、镇痛和抗骨质疏松作用。基于对临床医生的问卷调查以及对舒筋健腰丸研究文献的系统评价,采用国际临床实践指南制定方法,按照“循证、共识、经验”原则分析最佳现有证据和专家经验。全国30多位多学科专家制定了《舒筋健腰丸临床应用专家共识(GS/CACM267 - 2019)》,旨在指导和规范临床医生合理使用舒筋健腰丸,提高临床疗效和安全性。专家共识采用国际认可的证据分级推荐标准——GRADE。通过名义群体法形成专家共识。主要考虑六个方面,即证据质量、疗效、安全性、经济性、患者可接受性及其他因素。有充分证据时给出“推荐意见”,采用GRADE网格投票规则;证据不充分时形成“共识意见”,采用多数计数规则。根据舒筋健腰丸的适应证、用法用量、特殊人群用药及安全性等,提出1条推荐意见和9条共识意见。通过专家会议和函件方式,在全国范围内进行了咨询和同行评议。本共识适用于医院及基层医疗卫生服务机构的临床医生,为舒筋健腰丸的合理使用提供指导和参考。