Triantafyllidis Andreas, Polychronidou Eleftheria, Alexiadis Anastasios, Rocha Cleilton Lima, Oliveira Douglas Nogueira, da Silva Amanda S, Freire Ananda Lima, Macedo Crislanio, Sousa Igor Farias, Werbet Eriko, Lillo Elena Arredondo, Luengo Henar González, Ellacuría Macarena Torrego, Votis Konstantinos, Tzovaras Dimitrios
Information Technologies Institute, Centre for Research and Technology Hellas (CERTH), Thessaloniki, Greece.
Information Technologies Institute, Centre for Research and Technology Hellas (CERTH), Thessaloniki, Greece.
Artif Intell Med. 2020 Apr;104:101844. doi: 10.1016/j.artmed.2020.101844. Epub 2020 Mar 19.
Digital health interventions based on tools for Computerized Decision Support (CDS) and Machine Learning (ML), which take advantage of new information, sensing and communication technologies, can play a key role in childhood obesity prevention and treatment.
We present a systematic literature review of CDS and ML applications for the prevention and treatment of childhood obesity. The main characteristics and outcomes of studies using CDS and ML are demonstrated, to advance our understanding towards the development of smart and effective interventions for childhood obesity care.
A search in the bibliographic databases of PubMed and Scopus was performed to identify childhood obesity studies incorporating either CDS interventions, or advanced data analytics through ML algorithms. Ongoing, case, and qualitative studies, along with those not providing specific quantitative outcomes were excluded. The studies incorporating CDS were synthesized according to the intervention's main technology (e.g., mobile app), design type (e.g., randomized controlled trial), number of enrolled participants, target age of children, participants' follow-up duration, primary outcome (e.g., Body Mass Index (BMI)), and main CDS feature(s) and their outcomes (e.g., alerts for caregivers when BMI is high). The studies incorporating ML were synthesized according to the number of subjects included and their age, the ML algorithm(s) used (e.g., logistic regression), as well as their main outcome (e.g., prediction of obesity).
The literature search identified 8 studies incorporating CDS interventions and 9 studies utilizing ML algorithms, which met our eligibility criteria. All studies reported statistically significant interventional or ML model outcomes (e.g., in terms of accuracy). More than half of the interventional studies (n = 5, 63 %) were designed as randomized controlled trials. Half of the interventional studies (n = 4, 50 %) utilized Electronic Health Records (EHRs) and alerts for BMI as means of CDS. From the 9 studies using ML, the highest percentage targeted at the prognosis of obesity (n = 4, 44 %). In the studies incorporating more than one ML algorithms and reporting accuracy, it was shown that decision trees and artificial neural networks can accurately predict childhood obesity.
This review has found that CDS tools can be useful for the self-management or remote medical management of childhood obesity, whereas ML algorithms such as decision trees and artificial neural networks can be helpful for prediction purposes. Further rigorous studies in the area of CDS and ML for childhood obesity care are needed, considering the low number of studies identified in this review, their methodological limitations, and the scarcity of interventional studies incorporating ML algorithms in CDS tools.
基于计算机化决策支持(CDS)工具和机器学习(ML)的数字健康干预措施利用了新的信息、传感和通信技术,在儿童肥胖的预防和治疗中可以发挥关键作用。
我们对用于预防和治疗儿童肥胖的CDS和ML应用进行了系统的文献综述。展示了使用CDS和ML的研究的主要特征和结果,以增进我们对开发智能且有效的儿童肥胖护理干预措施的理解。
在PubMed和Scopus的文献数据库中进行检索,以识别纳入CDS干预措施或通过ML算法进行高级数据分析的儿童肥胖研究。排除正在进行的研究、病例研究和定性研究,以及那些未提供具体定量结果的研究。纳入CDS的研究根据干预的主要技术(如移动应用程序)、设计类型(如随机对照试验)、纳入参与者的数量、儿童的目标年龄、参与者的随访持续时间、主要结局(如体重指数(BMI))以及主要CDS特征及其结果(如BMI高时向护理人员发出警报)进行综合分析。纳入ML的研究根据纳入的受试者数量及其年龄、使用的ML算法(如逻辑回归)以及其主要结局(如肥胖预测)进行综合分析。
文献检索确定了8项纳入CDS干预措施的研究和9项使用ML算法的研究,这些研究符合我们的纳入标准。所有研究均报告了具有统计学意义的干预或ML模型结果(如在准确性方面)。超过一半的干预研究(n = 5,63%)设计为随机对照试验。一半的干预研究(n = 4,50%)利用电子健康记录(EHRs)和BMI警报作为CDS手段。在使用ML的9项研究中,针对肥胖预后的研究比例最高(n = 4,44%)。在纳入多种ML算法并报告准确性的研究中,结果表明决策树和人工神经网络可以准确预测儿童肥胖。
本综述发现,CDS工具可用于儿童肥胖的自我管理或远程医疗管理,而决策树和人工神经网络等ML算法有助于预测。考虑到本综述中识别出的研究数量较少、其方法学局限性以及在CDS工具中纳入ML算法的干预研究稀缺,在儿童肥胖护理的CDS和ML领域需要进一步进行严格的研究。