Carroll Paul A, Yeung Jonathan C, Darling Gail E
Division of Thoracic Surgery, Toronto General Hospital, University Health Network, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Division of Thoracic Surgery, Toronto General Hospital, University Health Network, Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Ann Thorac Surg. 2020 Nov;110(5):1706-1713. doi: 10.1016/j.athoracsur.2020.04.072. Epub 2020 Jun 3.
Feeding jejunostomy is frequently used to ensure nutritional intake after esophagectomy. Early return to diet is demonstrated to enhance recovery in major abdominal surgery. Early oral feeding is safe and effective in recent randomized controlled trials in esophagectomy. This study assesses the implications of eliminating the insertion of jejunostomy after esophagectomy.
A retrospective study was undertaken between 2014 and 2017 with follow-up over the first year. Fifty patients did not have a jejunostomy, compared with 46 patients who had conventional treatment. Outcomes measured included change in relative weight and body mass over 1 year, complications, and nutritional reinterventions.
Median weight loss at 1 year was 10.7 kg (range, -8 to 55.6) whereas median percent weight loss was 12% (range, -10.1% to 39.2%). Patients without jejunostomy lost more weight during the first month (P = .002). Thereafter, at 6 of 12 months, there were no differences in actual or relative weight loss. Obese patients lost more weight in the group without jejunostomy compared with those who had it (9.9 versus 5 kg; P = .004). This effect was not seen in normal or overweight patients. Complications were similar, whereas leaks were more common in the jejunostomy group (15.2% versus 2%; P = .019). Nutritional reinterventions were similar during index admission and subsequent readmissions (7 versus 5 patients; P = .640).
Routine jejunostomy use delays rather than prevents weight loss after esophagectomy. Oral route nutrition allows patients to maintain sufficient nutrition and does not increase complications or requirement for nutritional interventions after surgery. Routine use of jejunostomy may not be required in modern practice.
空肠造口喂养常用于食管癌切除术后确保营养摄入。早期恢复经口饮食已被证明可促进腹部大手术的恢复。在近期食管癌切除术的随机对照试验中,早期经口喂养是安全有效的。本研究评估食管癌切除术后不进行空肠造口术的影响。
2014年至2017年进行了一项回顾性研究,并对第一年进行随访。50例患者未行空肠造口术,46例患者接受传统治疗。测量的结果包括1年内相对体重和体重的变化、并发症以及营养再干预情况。
1年时体重减轻的中位数为10.7kg(范围为-8至55.6),而体重减轻百分比的中位数为12%(范围为-10.1%至39.2%)。未行空肠造口术的患者在第一个月体重减轻更多(P = 0.002)。此后,在12个月中的6个月,实际或相对体重减轻没有差异。与行空肠造口术的患者相比,肥胖患者在未行空肠造口术的组中体重减轻更多(9.9kg对5kg;P = 0.004)。在正常或超重患者中未观察到这种效应。并发症相似,但空肠造口术组的吻合口漏更常见(15.2%对2%;P = 0.019)。在首次住院和随后再次住院期间,营养再干预情况相似(7例对5例患者;P = 0.640)。
食管癌切除术后常规使用空肠造口术会延迟而非预防体重减轻。经口营养途径可使患者维持足够的营养,且不会增加术后并发症或营养干预的需求。在现代实践中可能无需常规使用空肠造口术。