Cianchetti Carlo
Department of Child and Adolescent Neuropsychiatry, University of Cagliari, Cagliari, Italy.
Clin Pract Epidemiol Ment Health. 2020 Mar 18;16:7-16. doi: 10.2174/1745017902016010007. eCollection 2020.
Early detection of behavioral and emotional problems in children and adolescents is relevant. For this purpose, the use of questionnaires completed by parents is applicable. Parent questionnaires are also useful preliminary support to the clinical investigation.
Validated tools for the analysis of behavioral and emotional problems suitable for school-age subjects are analyzed in their characteristics and possibilities of use.
The following are the main characteristics of the instruments examined. The Child and Adolescent Symptom Inventory 4&5, Parent Checklist (CASI-4&5) and Behavior Assessment System For Children - Parent Rating Scales 2&3 (BASC-2&3) include a high number of questions, with exploration extended to almost all possible pathologies.The Child Behavior Check-List (CBCL) has less items (113), but only 48 refer to DSM pathologies. The use of CASI, BASC and CBCL carries a cost because they are copyrighted.The Pediatric Symptom Checklist (PSC) has 35 items, but only 17 have a reference to 3 clinical areas. The Strength & Difficulties Questionnaire (SDA) is very short (25 items) and concerns only the main externalizing and internalizing disorders. The Child and Adolescent Behavior Inventory (CABI) has 75 items and explores a wide range of psycho-pathological issues, likewise CASI and BASC. PSC, SDA and CABI can be used free of charge.
The comparison of the characteristics of the aforementioned questionnaires can guide the psychiatrist and the epidemiologist in choosing the most suitable tool for what is proposed to be assessed, in relation to practicability, extension of the areas explored and costs.
儿童和青少年行为及情绪问题的早期发现具有重要意义。为此,采用由家长填写的问卷是可行的。家长问卷也是临床调查的有用初步支持。
分析适用于学龄儿童的行为和情绪问题分析的经过验证的工具的特点及使用可能性。
以下是所检查工具的主要特点。《儿童与青少年症状量表4&5家长检查表》(CASI - 4&5)和《儿童行为评估系统 - 家长评定量表2&3》(BASC - 2&3)包含大量问题,对几乎所有可能的病症都有涉及。《儿童行为检查表》(CBCL)项目较少(113项),但仅有48项涉及《精神疾病诊断与统计手册》中的病症。使用CASI、BASC和CBCL需要成本,因为它们受版权保护。《儿科症状检查表》(PSC)有35项,但仅有17项涉及3个临床领域。《长处与困难问卷》(SDA)非常简短(25项),仅涉及主要的外化和内化障碍。《儿童与青少年行为量表》(CABI)有75项,探索广泛的心理病理问题,与CASI和BASC类似。PSC、SDA和CABI可免费使用。
上述问卷特点的比较可指导精神科医生和流行病学家根据实用性、探索领域的广度和成本,选择最适合所提议评估内容的工具。