Schiff Rachel, Rosenstock Shlomit, Ravid Dorit
School of Education, Faculty of Social Sciences, Bar Ilan University, Ramat Gan, Israel.
The Lester and Sally Entin Faculty of Humanities, The Jaime and Joan Constantiner School of Education, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv, Israel.
Front Psychol. 2020 May 26;11:868. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2020.00868. eCollection 2020.
The current study examined the factors underlying native Hebrew speakers' ability to learn homophonous affix spelling. It takes a novel view in investigating the effect of morpho-orthographic complexity of affix representation on the development of affix spelling across the school years. The role of five morpho-orthographic principles in homophonous affix letter spelling was studied: (i) morpho-orthographic transparency; (ii) affix letter prevalence; (iii) morpho-phonological competition; (iv) overtness of the phonological-orthographic link; and (v) phono-morpho-orthographic consistency. Taken together, these five principles of affix spelling constitute complexity metrics that pinpoint the loci of spelling challenge in homophonous Hebrew affixes. Study participants were 83 monolingual Hebrew-speaking students in four grade levels - 2nd, 4th, 7th, and 10th grades. The research instrument was a spelling task of 244 words containing affix letters in 57 morphological categories. The affixes appearing in the target words represented 56 different affix categories, covering all non-root morphological roles, both inflectional and derivational. While correct spelling increased across grade levels, a hierarchy emerged in interaction with grade level regarding these criteria: Younger spellers were mostly assisted by morpho-orthographic sites, morphological category frequency, and phonological transparency - while spelling in higher grade levels was more affected by morpho-orthographic prevalence. Thus, knowledge of how morphological roles are deployed in the orthography emerges as the most significant factor that affects learning to spell affix letters in Hebrew.
本研究考察了以希伯来语为母语者学习同音词缀拼写能力背后的因素。在调查词缀表征的形态正字法复杂性对整个学年词缀拼写发展的影响方面,本研究提出了一种新颖的观点。研究了五条形态正字法原则在同音词缀字母拼写中的作用:(i)形态正字法透明度;(ii)词缀字母出现频率;(iii)形态语音竞争;(iv)语音正字法联系的显性程度;以及(v)语音形态正字法一致性。综合起来,这五条词缀拼写原则构成了复杂性指标,明确了希伯来语同音词缀拼写挑战的所在位置。研究参与者是83名单语希伯来语学生,分四个年级——二年级、四年级、七年级和十年级。研究工具是一项拼写任务,包含244个单词,这些单词包含57个形态类别中的词缀字母。目标单词中出现的词缀代表56个不同的词缀类别,涵盖所有非词根形态角色,包括屈折和派生。虽然正确拼写在各年级有所增加,但在与年级水平的交互作用中,就这些标准而言出现了一种层级关系:年龄较小的拼写者大多受到形态正字法位置、形态类别频率和语音透明度的帮助——而较高年级的拼写则更多地受到形态正字法出现频率的影响。因此,关于形态角色在正字法中如何分布的知识成为影响希伯来语词缀字母拼写学习的最重要因素。