Department of Immunology, Genetics and Pathology, Uppsala University, Uppsala, Sweden.
Curr Opin Oncol. 2020 Jul;32(4):377-383. doi: 10.1097/CCO.0000000000000641.
The value of adjuvant chemotherapy in rectal cancer is controversial with opinions varying from 'not be used' since randomized trials have not shown significant gains to 'be used as in colon cancer' as the need is the same and colon and rectal cancers are quite similar. This review will look upon data critically and with open eyes.
With the exception of one randomized phase II trial (ADORE) revealing a significant gain in disease-free survival using one more effective regimen (mFOLFOX) than bolus 5-fluorouracil leucovorin, no new data have been presented. However, bringing up aspects in previous trials, either considered irrelevant for the present situation or overall negative, of what adjuvant treatment can achieve, a small reduction (hazard ratio about 0.8) in the risk of recurrence is present. This reduction is not fundamentally different from that in colon cancer considering that adjuvant treatment for rectal cancer cannot be initiated as rapidly as it can after a colon cancer diagnosis.
Adjuvant chemotherapy after rectal cancer surgery reduces recurrence risks but the benefit is limited and for most patients not clinically relevant. Neoadjuvant therapy can be more effective but results from randomized trials are not yet available.
辅助化疗在直肠癌中的价值存在争议,意见不一,从“不应使用”(因为随机试验并未显示出显著获益)到“应像结肠癌一样使用”(因为需求相同,且结肠和直肠肿瘤非常相似)。本文将批判性地、客观地看待数据。
除了一项随机二期试验(ADORE)显示使用一种更有效的方案(mFOLFOX)比氟尿嘧啶/亚叶酸钙 5-氟尿嘧啶推注方案多一个周期治疗可显著提高无病生存率外,目前尚无新的数据。然而,回顾之前试验中的一些方面,无论是考虑到目前情况无关紧要还是总体上为负面的,辅助治疗能达到的效果,即复发风险降低(风险比约为 0.8)。考虑到直肠癌的辅助治疗不能像结肠癌那样迅速开始,这种降低与结肠癌并无根本区别。
直肠癌手术后辅助化疗可降低复发风险,但获益有限,对大多数患者而言无临床意义。新辅助治疗可能更有效,但随机试验结果尚未公布。