Dipartimento di Scienze e Tecnologie Agro-Alimentari, Alma Mater Studiorum Università di Bologna, Italy.
Dipartimento di Scienze e Tecnologie Agro-Alimentari, Alma Mater Studiorum Università di Bologna, Italy.
Chemosphere. 2020 Nov;258:127358. doi: 10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.127358. Epub 2020 Jun 11.
Honey bee mortality and colony losses have been reported worldwide. Although this phenomenon is caused by a combination of factors, agrochemicals have received special attention due to their potential effects on bees. In agricultural and urban environments bees are exposed to several compounds that may interact in unexpected ways, but information on the extent of pesticide exposure remains unclear. Several monitoring studies have been conducted to evaluate the field-realistic exposure of bees to pesticides after their release on the market. However, their outputs are difficult to compare and harmonize due to differences in the analytical methodologies and the sampling protocols (e.g. number of screened compounds and analysed samples, and detection limits (LODs)). Here, we hypothesize that the analytical methodologies used in the monitoring studies may strongly affect the pesticide occurrences in pollen underestimating the real pesticide exposure. By mean of a systematic literature review, we have collected relevant information on pesticide contaminations in the honey bee-collected pollen. Our findings showed that the pesticide occurrences were associated with the analytical methodologies and the real pesticide exposure has likely been underestimated in some monitoring studies. For four highly toxic compounds, the LOD used in these monitoring studies exceeded the doses that cause toxic effects on honey bees. We recommend that, especially for the highly toxic compounds, the LODs used in the monitoring studies should be low enough to exclude lethal or sublethal effects on bees and avoid "false negative" samples.
蜜蜂的死亡率和蜂群损失在全球范围内都有报道。尽管这种现象是由多种因素共同造成的,但由于农用化学品可能对蜜蜂产生潜在影响,因此它们受到了特别关注。在农业和城市环境中,蜜蜂会接触到几种可能以意想不到的方式相互作用的化合物,但有关蜜蜂接触农药的程度的信息仍不清楚。已经进行了几项监测研究,以评估在市场上投放农药后蜜蜂在田间的实际暴露情况。然而,由于分析方法和采样方案(例如筛选的化合物和分析样本的数量以及检测限(LOD))存在差异,它们的结果难以比较和协调。在这里,我们假设监测研究中使用的分析方法可能会严重影响花粉中农药的出现情况,从而低估蜜蜂的实际农药暴露情况。通过系统的文献综述,我们收集了有关蜜蜂采集的花粉中农药污染的相关信息。我们的研究结果表明,农药的出现与分析方法有关,并且在一些监测研究中,蜜蜂的实际农药暴露情况可能被低估了。对于四种高毒性化合物,这些监测研究中使用的 LOD 超过了对蜜蜂产生毒性影响的剂量。我们建议,特别是对于高毒性化合物,监测研究中使用的 LOD 应足够低,以排除对蜜蜂的致死或亚致死影响,并避免“假阴性”样本。