Kim Bo-Kyung Elizabeth, Quinn Camille R, Logan-Greene Patricia, DiClemente Ralph, Voisin Dexter
USC Suzanne Dworak-Peck School of Social Work, University of Southern California, 669 W 34 Street, SWC 218, Los Angeles, CA 90089, United States.
College of Social Work, The Ohio State University, 325U Stillman Hall, 1947 College Road, Columbus, OH 43210, United States.
Child Youth Serv Rev. 2020 Jan;108. doi: 10.1016/j.childyouth.2019.104648. Epub 2019 Nov 28.
Behaviors like truancy, running away, curfew violation, and alcohol possession fall under the status offense category and can have serious consequences for adolescents. The Juvenile Justice and Delinquency and Prevention Act prohibited detaining status offenders. We explored the degree to which African American adolescent girls were being detained for status offenses and the connections to their behavioral health risks and re-confinement.
188 African American girls (aged 13-17), recruited from detention facilities, were surveyed at baseline and 3-month follow-ups. Logistic regression models estimated the likelihood of longitudinal re-confinement, controlling for sexual and behavioral health risk factors.
One third of the overall sample was detained for a status offense. Status offenders were exposed to higher peer risk profiles. At follow-up, nearly 39% of status offenders reported re-confinement. Compared to youth with other offenses, those who violated a court order (type of status offense) were 3 times more likely to be re-confined. Controlling for sexual and behavioral health risk factors, the odds of re-confinement was not statistically significant.
Overall findings suggest that courts and detention facilities must devote specialized resources to addressing the socio-behavioral needs of African American girls with status offenses so as not to use detention as an intervention.
逃学、离家出走、违反宵禁和持有酒精等行为属于身份犯罪类别,可能会给青少年带来严重后果。《少年司法与预防犯罪法》禁止拘留身份犯罪者。我们探讨了非裔美国少女因身份犯罪被拘留的程度,以及与她们行为健康风险和再次被监禁的关联。
从拘留设施招募了188名非裔美国女孩(年龄在13至17岁之间),在基线和3个月随访时进行调查。逻辑回归模型估计了纵向再次被监禁的可能性,并控制了性健康和行为健康风险因素。
总体样本中有三分之一因身份犯罪被拘留。身份犯罪者面临更高的同伴风险状况。在随访时,近39%的身份犯罪者报告再次被监禁。与犯其他罪行的青少年相比,违反法院命令(身份犯罪类型)的青少年再次被监禁的可能性高出3倍。在控制了性健康和行为健康风险因素后,再次被监禁的几率在统计学上不显著。
总体研究结果表明,法院和拘留设施必须投入专门资源,以满足犯身份犯罪的非裔美国女孩的社会行为需求,从而避免将拘留用作一种干预手段。