Quinn Camille R
Center for Equitable Family and Community Well-Being, School of Social Work, University of Michigan, 1080 South University Avenue, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA.
Behav Sci (Basel). 2025 Jan 1;15(1):31. doi: 10.3390/bs15010031.
This review critically evaluates the existing literature on youth punishment system (YPS)-involved Black girls and their intersections of with trauma and post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). It synthesizes findings from previous studies, identifying key research trends, gaps, and controversies, while also highlighting areas in need of further investigation. Black girls, particularly those involved in systems such as juvenile justice, child welfare, and education, often face disproportionate exposure to violence, abuse and neglect, trauma, and systemic racism. For Black girls with histories of trauma and PTSD, these intersecting challenges are compounded by the added vulnerabilities of race, gender, and YPS involvement. This article argues that addressing the complex needs of this population requires recognition that Black girls' harm is criminalized and, therefore, inextricably linked to their YPS-involvement, so a comprehensive, culturally responsive approach that includes trauma-informed care, healing-centered engagement, and holistic support systems are needed. Equitable access to tailored mental health services, educational resources, and culturally relevant interventions is essential to mitigate the long-term effects of trauma, promote resilience, and foster healing. Additionally, advocacy efforts to dismantle systemic harm and address racial and gender disparities are critical for creating inclusive environments that empower and support Black girls in these systems. By centering their lived experiences, this review emphasizes the importance of fostering environments of healing, justice, and equity for this vulnerable population.
本综述批判性地评估了现有关于涉及青少年惩罚系统(YPS)的黑人女孩及其与创伤和创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)交集的文献。它综合了以往研究的结果,确定了关键的研究趋势、差距和争议,同时也突出了需要进一步调查的领域。黑人女孩,尤其是那些涉及少年司法、儿童福利和教育等系统的女孩,往往面临着不成比例的暴力、虐待和忽视、创伤以及系统性种族主义。对于有创伤和PTSD病史的黑人女孩来说,种族、性别和YPS参与带来的额外脆弱性使这些交叉挑战更加复杂。本文认为,满足这一人群的复杂需求需要认识到黑人女孩的伤害被刑事化,因此与她们参与YPS有着千丝万缕的联系,所以需要一种全面的、具有文化响应性的方法,包括创伤知情护理、以康复为中心的参与和整体支持系统。公平获得量身定制的心理健康服务、教育资源和具有文化相关性的干预措施对于减轻创伤的长期影响、促进恢复力和促进康复至关重要。此外,消除系统性伤害以及解决种族和性别差异的宣传工作对于创造包容的环境至关重要,这种环境能够赋予这些系统中的黑人女孩权力并为其提供支持。通过以她们的生活经历为中心,本综述强调了为这一弱势群体营造康复、正义和平等环境的重要性。