Seidel Lavinia, Nebel Kathrin, Achenbach Stephan, Bauer Ulrike, Ewert Peter, Freilinger Sebastian, Gundlach Ulrike, Kaemmerer Harald, Nagdyman Nicole, Oberhoffer Renate, Pieper Lars, Reinhard Wibke, Sanftenberg Linda, Schelling Jörg, Weyand Michael, Neidenbach Rhoia
Department of Congenital Heart Disease and Paediatric Cardiology, German Heart Centre Munich, Technical University Munich, 80636 Munich, Germany.
Department of Cardiology, University of Erlangen, 91054 Erlangen, Germany.
J Clin Med. 2020 Jun 22;9(6):1943. doi: 10.3390/jcm9061943.
: Due to the increase in survival rates for congenital heart disease (CHD) in the last decades, over 90% of patients today reach adulthood. Currently, there are more than 300,000 adults with CHD (ACHD) living in Germany. They have an increased need for specialized medical care, since almost all ACHD have chronic heart disease and suffer from specific chronic symptoms, risks, and sequelae. Primary care physicians (PCPs) play a crucial role in referring patients to ACHD specialists or specialized institutions. This cross-sectional study is intended to clarify the real-world care of ACHD from the PCP's perspective. This analysis, initiated by the German Heart Centre Munich, was based on a 27-item questionnaire on actual ACHD health care practice in Germany from the PCP's perspective. : In total, 767 questionnaires were considered valid for inclusion. The majority of the PCPs were general practitioners (95.9%), and 84.1% had cared for ACHD during the past year. A majority (69.2%) of the PCPs had cared for patients with simple CHD, while 50.6% and 33.4% had cared for patients with moderate and severe CHD, respectively, in all age groups. PCPs treated almost all typical residual symptoms and sequelae, and advised patients regarding difficult questions, including exercise capacity, pregnancy, genetics, and insurance matters. However, 33.8% of the PCPs did not even know about the existence of certified ACHD specialists or centers. Only 23.9% involved an ACHD-specialized physician in their treatment. In cases of severe cardiac issues, 70.8% of the PCPs referred patients to ACHD-certified centers. Although 52.5% of the PCPs were not sufficiently informed about existing structures, 64.2% rated the current care situation as either "very good" or "good". Only 26.3% ( = 190) of the responding physicians were aware of patient organizations for ACHD. : The present study showed that the majority of PCPs are not informed about the ACHD care structures available in Germany. The need for specialized ACHD follow-up care is largely underestimated, with an urgent need for optimization to reduce morbidity and mortality. For the future, solutions must be developed to integrate PCPs more intensively into the ACHD care network.
由于过去几十年先天性心脏病(CHD)患者生存率的提高,如今超过90%的患者能够活到成年。目前,德国有超过30万成年先天性心脏病患者(ACHD)。他们对专科医疗护理的需求增加,因为几乎所有ACHD患者都患有慢性心脏病,并遭受特定的慢性症状、风险和后遗症。初级保健医生(PCP)在将患者转诊至ACHD专科医生或专科机构方面发挥着关键作用。这项横断面研究旨在从PCP的角度阐明ACHD在现实世界中的护理情况。这项由慕尼黑德国心脏中心发起的分析,基于一份从PCP角度出发的关于德国ACHD实际医疗实践的27项问卷。
总共767份问卷被认为可纳入有效分析。大多数PCP是全科医生(95.9%),84.1%的PCP在过去一年中护理过ACHD患者。大多数(69.2%)PCP护理过患有简单CHD的患者,而在所有年龄组中,分别有50.6%和33.4%的PCP护理过患有中度和重度CHD的患者。PCP几乎治疗了所有典型的残留症状和后遗症,并就包括运动能力、怀孕、遗传学和保险事宜等难题为患者提供建议。然而,33.8%的PCP甚至不知道有经过认证的ACHD专科医生或中心存在。只有23.9%在治疗过程中会咨询ACHD专科医生。在出现严重心脏问题的情况下,70.8%的PCP会将患者转诊至有ACHD认证的中心。尽管52.5%的PCP对现有医疗体系了解不足,但64.2%的PCP将当前的护理情况评为“非常好”或“好”。只有26.3%(即190名)的受访医生知晓ACHD患者组织。
本研究表明,大多数PCP不了解德国现有的ACHD护理体系。对ACHD专科后续护理的需求在很大程度上被低估,迫切需要进行优化以降低发病率和死亡率。未来,必须制定解决方案,以便更深入地将PCP纳入ACHD护理网络。