Rustaden Anne Mette, Gjestvang Christina, Bø Kari, Haakstad Lene Annette Hagen, Paulsen Gøran
Department of Sports Medicine, Norwegian School of Sport Sciences, Oslo, Norway.
Front Physiol. 2020 Jun 10;11:570. doi: 10.3389/fphys.2020.00570. eCollection 2020.
High-repetition, low-load resistance exercise in group class settings has gained popularity in recent years, with BodyPump as a prime example. For individuals using exercise for body-weight management, the energy expenditure during exercise is of interest. Therefore, we herein aimed to estimate the energy expenditure during a session of BodyPump and a time-matched session of heavy load resistance training in overweight women (BMI ≥ 25.0).
Eighteen women participated in the study (mean age 35.4 years ± 10.2, BMI 30.4 kg/m ± 4.8), 10 exercising BodyPump (50-100 repetitions each muscle group) and eight performed a heavy load session (eight repetition maximum × three sets). The energy expenditure was assessed with indirect calorimetry during the sessions and for two intervals at rest during the recovery phase: 0-20 and 120-140 min after the sessions.
The BodyPump group lifted significantly more loads than the heavy load group (19,485 kg ± 2258 vs 15,616 kg ± 2976, = 0.006), while energy expenditure was similar with 302 kcal ± 67 and 289 kcal ± 69 in BodyPump and heavy load group, respectively ( = 0.69). With no group differences, the resting metabolic rate (RMR) was elevated with 15-22% 2 h after exercise.
Overweight women achieved an energy expenditure of approximately 300 kcal (4.7 kcal per min) during a single session of BodyPump, which was similar with the women performing a single session of heavy load resistance exercise.
近年来,在团体课程环境中进行的高重复次数、低负荷阻力训练越来越受欢迎,杠铃操就是一个典型例子。对于通过运动来控制体重的个体而言,运动期间的能量消耗备受关注。因此,我们在此旨在估算超重女性(体重指数≥25.0)进行一次杠铃操课程以及一次时间匹配的大负荷阻力训练课程期间的能量消耗。
18名女性参与了该研究(平均年龄35.4岁±10.2,体重指数30.4kg/m²±4.8),其中10人进行杠铃操训练(每个肌肉群进行50 - 100次重复),8人进行大负荷训练课程(每组最大重复次数为8次,共三组)。在训练课程期间以及恢复阶段的两个休息时间段(训练课程结束后0 - 20分钟和120 - 140分钟),通过间接测热法评估能量消耗。
杠铃操组举起的负荷明显多于大负荷组(19485千克±2258对15616千克±2976,P = 0.006),而能量消耗相似,杠铃操组和大负荷组分别为302千卡±67和289千卡±69(P = 0.69)。两组之间无差异,运动后2小时静息代谢率(RMR)升高了15 - 22%。
超重女性在一次杠铃操课程期间的能量消耗约为300千卡(每分钟4.7千卡),这与进行一次大负荷阻力运动的女性相似。