Correll Darin J, Kissin Igor
The Department of Anesthesiology, Perioperative and Pain Medicine, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts.
The Department of Anesthesiology, Perioperative and Pain Medicine, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts.
J Anesth Hist. 2020 Jun;6(2):84-89. doi: 10.1016/j.janh.2019.08.003. Epub 2019 Sep 6.
One of the most interesting signs of growth in a medical specialty is the addition of pain medicine as a clinical subspecialty to it. The aim of this study was to analyze publication-based academic interest in pain medicine among clinical specialties with long-standing involvement in pain management.
We assessed the activity within several specialties in the development of an academic foundation for pain medicine by measuring the frequency of the most common pain topics (1998-2017) in academic journals representing such specialties. The selection of materials for the analysis of publication-based academic interest associated with the development of pain medicine followed a three-step process: (1) Medical specialties, limited to those with accredited fellowship training in pain medicine for more than 20 years - anesthesiology, neurology, physiatry, and psychiatry; (2) Pain topics, based on the degree of topic association with the work of pain clinics - a total of 34 topics; (3) Specialty journals, mostly official journals of societies publishing articles representing all aspects of a specialty - four journals per specialty. Specialty-related academic interest was characterized in two dimensions: its breadth (the number of different topics of interest with distinctly high shares of publications) and its intensity (maximal number of publications on a particular topic).
According to the number of topics with a distinctly high share of articles per topic (≥ 5%), the rank order of specialties was as follows (of 34 topics): anesthesiology (22), physiatry (20), neurology (10), and psychiatry (0). Regarding comparative intensity of interest, anesthesiology has prevailing interest in 16 topics (especially in postoperative pain and pharmacologic pain treatment), physiatry in 13 topics (especially in physical methods of pain therapy), and neurology in one topic (headache disorders).
Publication-based academic interest in pain management was most intensive in two specialties, anesthesiology and physiatry, with anesthesiology being somewhat more multifaceted, especially in the methods of pain treatment.
医学专科发展中最有趣的迹象之一是将疼痛医学作为一个临床亚专科纳入其中。本研究的目的是分析长期参与疼痛管理的临床专科中基于出版物的对疼痛医学的学术兴趣。
我们通过测量代表这些专科的学术期刊中最常见疼痛主题(1998 - 2017年)的出现频率,评估了几个专科在疼痛医学学术基础发展方面的活动。选择用于分析与疼痛医学发展相关的基于出版物的学术兴趣的材料遵循三个步骤:(1)医学专科,限于那些拥有经认可的疼痛医学专科培训超过20年的专科——麻醉学、神经病学、物理医学与康复学和精神病学;(2)疼痛主题,基于主题与疼痛诊所工作的关联程度——共34个主题;(3)专科期刊,大多是各学会的官方期刊,发表代表一个专科各个方面的文章——每个专科4种期刊。与专科相关的学术兴趣在两个维度上进行表征:其广度(具有明显高比例出版物的不同感兴趣主题的数量)及其强度(特定主题上的最大出版物数量)。
根据每个主题文章占比明显较高(≥5%)的主题数量,专科的排名如下(共34个主题):麻醉学(22个)、物理医学与康复学(20个)、神经病学(10个)和精神病学(0个)。关于兴趣的相对强度,麻醉学在16个主题上具有主要兴趣(尤其在术后疼痛和药物性疼痛治疗方面),物理医学与康复学在13个主题上具有主要兴趣(尤其在疼痛治疗的物理方法方面),而神经病学在1个主题(头痛疾病)上具有主要兴趣。
基于出版物的对疼痛管理的学术兴趣在两个专科中最为强烈,即麻醉学和物理医学与康复学,麻醉学在某些方面更为多样,尤其是在疼痛治疗方法方面。