Kelly T, Surjan Y, Rinks M, Warren-Forward H
School of Health Sciences, University of Newcastle, Australia; Illawarra Shoalhaven Local Health District, Australia.
School of Health Sciences, University of Newcastle, Australia.
Radiography (Lond). 2021 Feb;27(1):59-66. doi: 10.1016/j.radi.2020.05.015. Epub 2020 Jun 25.
The University of Newcastle, Radiation Therapy degree (RT) includes a clinical reasoning module that provides students with the opportunity to learn and practice communication skills before their first clinical placement. This study investigates students' perceptions of how well the module prepared them for placement and explores students' perceptions of their communication experiences during placement.
A single survey was administered to students four months following placement (six months after delivery of module), and included a request for perceptions pre-module, post-module and pre and post placement via an online survey comprising 46 closed, Likert scale and open-response questions. Assessment of changes in student confidence, the value of preparation for placement and perceptions concerning interpersonal skills with patients and radiation therapists (RTTs) were examined. Survey data was analysed quantitatively (counts, Fisher's exact) assessing statistical differences in confidence and Weighted Sum Average (WSA) of Likert scales. Qualitative findings were supported by written comments.
Participants reported increasing confidence levels between pre-module (WSA - 1.13), and post-module (2.88), which was statistically significant (p = 0.039) and between pre-placement (2.0) and after placement (3.38), in their ability to communicate with patients. Similar changes in confidence were noted with interactions with RTTs (WSA scores 1.0, 2.13, 1.75, 3.25 resp). Students reported communication strategies prepared them well for patient interactions. Positive reinforcement from RTTs was acknowledged as creating immediate support of their current patient skills.
Undertaking the clinical reasoning module successfully increased students' confidence and provided opportunities to develop appropriate communication skills for placement.
Increased levels of confidence and positive reinforcement from RTTs should positively impact students' knowledge and skills, and provide introspection for improvement for future placements.
纽卡斯尔大学的放射治疗学位课程(RT)包含一个临床推理模块,该模块让学生有机会在首次临床实习前学习和练习沟通技巧。本研究调查了学生对该模块为实习所做准备程度的看法,并探讨了学生对实习期间沟通经历的看法。
在实习四个月后(模块授课六个月后)对学生进行了一次单一调查,通过一个包含46个封闭式、李克特量表式和开放式问题的在线调查,询问学生在模块学习前、学习后以及实习前和实习后的看法。考察了学生信心的变化、实习准备的价值以及对与患者和放射治疗师(RTT)人际交往技能的看法。对调查数据进行了定量分析(计数、费舍尔精确检验),以评估信心和李克特量表加权总和平均值(WSA)的统计差异。定性结果得到书面评论的支持。
参与者报告说,在与患者沟通的能力方面,模块学习前(WSA - 1.13)到模块学习后(2.88)信心水平有所提高,具有统计学意义(p = 0.039),实习前(2.0)到实习后(3.38)也是如此。与RTT互动时也注意到了类似的信心变化(WSA分数分别为1.0、2.13、1.75、3.25)。学生报告说沟通策略使他们能很好地应对与患者的互动。RTT的积极强化被认为对他们当前的患者沟通技能起到了即时支持作用。
参与临床推理模块成功提高了学生的信心,并为实习培养适当的沟通技能提供了机会。
信心水平的提高和RTT的积极强化应会对学生的知识和技能产生积极影响,并为未来实习的改进提供反思。