Hirvonen Kalle
Development Strategy and Governance Division, International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI), Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.
Health Econ. 2020 Oct;29(10):1316-1323. doi: 10.1002/hec.4128. Epub 2020 Jun 28.
The Journal of Health Economics and Health Economics are arguably the top two journals in the field of health economics. Together, they published 1,679 empirical research articles in the past decade (2010-2019). In line with analyses based on earlier periods, the empirical evidence in top health economics journals continues to be dominated by the United States (37% of all empirical articles), whereas studies based on low-income countries remain rare (2%). Countries with higher disease burdens receive generally less attention from health economists publishing at the top of their field. Reflecting this, more research was published based on data from the Nordic countries (27 million people) than from sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia regions combined (2.9 billion people). Finally, one-third of the empirical articles did not indicate the country of evidence in the title or the abstract, possibly to signal external validity of the findings. This practice was particularly common for articles based on data from North America with more than half of the articles omitting the country of evidence from the title and the abstract. The study concludes by exploring some hypotheses that may explain these findings.
《健康经济学杂志》和《健康经济学》可以说是健康经济学领域排名前两位的期刊。在过去十年(2010 - 2019年)里,它们共发表了1679篇实证研究文章。与基于早期阶段的分析一致,顶级健康经济学期刊中的实证证据仍然以美国为主(占所有实证文章的37%),而基于低收入国家的研究仍然很少(占2%)。疾病负担较重的国家通常较少受到该领域顶级健康经济学家发表研究的关注。反映在这一点上,基于北欧国家(2700万人)数据发表的研究比基于撒哈拉以南非洲和南亚地区(29亿人)数据发表的研究总和还要多。最后,三分之一的实证文章在标题或摘要中未标明证据来源国,这可能是为了表明研究结果的外部有效性。这种做法在基于北美数据的文章中尤为常见,超过一半的文章在标题和摘要中省略了证据来源国。该研究通过探讨一些可能解释这些发现的假设得出结论。