Kozakiewicz Marcin, Wach Tomasz
Department of Maxillofacial Surgery, Medical University in Lodz, Pl. Hallera 1, 90-647 Łódź, Poland.
Materials (Basel). 2020 Jun 30;13(13):2935. doi: 10.3390/ma13132935.
This article presents a comparison of bone replacement materials in terms of their ability to produce living bone image at the place of their implantation. Five bone replacement materials are compared (Osteovit-porous collagen, Cerasorb Foam-collagen scaffolding of synthetic β tricalcium phosphate, Osbone-synthetic hydroxyapatite, Endobone-deproteinized bovine-derived cancellous bone hydroxyapatite, and Cerasorb-synthetic β tricalcium phosphate). Intraoral radiographs are taken immediately after implantation and 12 months later. The texture analysis was performed to assess (texture index, TI) the level of structure chaos (entropy) in relation to the presence of longitudinal elements visible in radiographs (run length emphasis moment). The reference ratio of the chaotic trabecular pattern (Entropy) to the number of longitudinal structures, i.e., trabeculae (LngREmph), is 176:100 (i.e., 1.76 ± 0.28). Radiological homogeneity immediately after the implantation procedure is a result of the similar shape of its particles (Osbone, Endobone and Cerasorb) or radiolucency (Osteovit, Cerasorb Foam). The particles visible in radiographs were similar in the LngREmph parameters applied to the reference bone, but not in the co-occurrence matrix features. The TI for Osteovit during a 12-month follow-up period changed from 1.55 ± 0.26 to 1.48 ± 0.26 ( > 0.05), for Cerasorb Foam from 1.82 ± 0.27 to 1.63 ± 0.24 ( < 0.05), for Osbone from 1.97 ± 0.31 to 1.74 ± 0.30 ( < 0.01), and for Endobone from 1.86 ± 0.25 to 1.84 ± 0.25 ( > 0.05), The observed structure in the radiological image of bone substitute materials containing calcium phosphates obtains the characteristics of a living bone image after twelve months.
本文就骨替代材料在植入部位产生活骨影像的能力进行了比较。比较了五种骨替代材料(骨维特-多孔胶原蛋白、西拉斯博泡沫-合成β-磷酸三钙的胶原蛋白支架、奥斯骨-合成羟基磷灰石、内骨-脱蛋白牛源松质骨羟基磷灰石和西拉斯博-合成β-磷酸三钙)。在植入后立即和12个月后拍摄口腔内X光片。进行纹理分析以评估(纹理指数,TI)与X光片中可见的纵向元素(游程长度强调矩)相关的结构混乱程度(熵)。混乱的小梁模式(熵)与纵向结构(即小梁)数量(LngREmph)的参考比值为176:100(即1.76±0.28)。植入手术后立即出现的放射学均匀性是其颗粒形状相似(奥斯骨、内骨和西拉斯博)或射线透过性(骨维特、西拉斯博泡沫)的结果。X光片中可见的颗粒在应用于参考骨的LngREmph参数方面相似,但在共生矩阵特征方面不同。在12个月的随访期内,骨维特的TI从1.55±0.26变为1.48±0.26(>0.05),西拉斯博泡沫从1.82±0.27变为1.63±0.24(<0.05),奥斯骨从1.97±0.31变为1.74±0.30(<0.01),内骨从1.86±0.25变为1.84±0.25(>0.05)。含有磷酸钙的骨替代材料的放射影像中观察到的结构在十二个月后获得了活骨影像的特征。