Parnassia Addiction Research Centre (PARC), Parnassia Psychiatric Institute, The Hague, The Netherlands,
Curium, Department of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, Leiden University Medical Center, Leiden, The Netherlands,
Eur Addict Res. 2020;26(4-5):223-232. doi: 10.1159/000508385. Epub 2020 Jul 7.
Childhood attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is a risk factor for substance misuse and substance use disorder (SUD) in adolescence and (early) adulthood. ADHD and SUD also frequently co-occur in treatment-seeking adolescents, which complicates diagnosis and treatment and is associated with poor treatment outcomes. Research on the effect of treatment of childhood ADHD on the prevention of adolescent SUD is inconclusive, and studies on the diagnosis and treatment of adolescents with ADHD and SUD are scarce. Thus, the available evidence is generally not sufficient to justify robust treatment recommendations.
The aim of the study was to obtain a consensus statement based on a combination of scientific data and clinical experience.
A modified Delphi study to reach consensus based upon the combination of scientific data and clinical experience with a multidisciplinary group of 55 experts from 17 countries. The experts were asked to rate a set of statements on the effect of treatment of childhood ADHD on adolescent SUD and on the screening, diagnosis, and treatment of adolescents with comorbid ADHD and SUD.
After 3 iterative rounds of rating and adapting 37 statements, consensus was reached on 36 of these statements representing 6 domains: general (n = 4), risk of developing SUD (n = 3), screening and diagnosis (n = 7), psychosocial treatment (n = 5), pharmacological treatment (n = 11), and complementary treatments (n = 7). Routine screening is recommended for ADHD in adolescent patients in substance abuse treatment and for SUD in adolescent patients with ADHD in mental healthcare settings. Long-acting stimulants are recommended as the first-line treatment of ADHD in adolescents with concurrent ADHD and SUD, and pharmacotherapy should preferably be embedded in psychosocial treatment. The only remaining no-consensus statement concerned the requirement of abstinence before starting pharmacological treatment in adolescents with ADHD and concurrent SUD. In contrast to the majority, some experts required full abstinence before starting any pharmacological treatment, some were against the use of stimulants in the treatment of these patients (independent of abstinence), while some were against the alternative use of bupropion.
This international consensus statement can be used by clinicians and patients together in a shared decision-making process to select the best interventions and to reach optimal outcomes in adolescent patients with concurrent ADHD and SUD.
儿童期注意缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)是青少年和(早期)成年期物质使用障碍(SUD)的一个风险因素。ADHD 和 SUD 在寻求治疗的青少年中也经常同时发生,这使得诊断和治疗变得复杂,并与治疗效果不佳有关。关于治疗儿童期 ADHD 对预防青少年 SUD 的影响的研究结果尚无定论,且关于患有 ADHD 和 SUD 的青少年的诊断和治疗的研究也很少。因此,现有证据通常不足以支持强有力的治疗建议。
本研究旨在基于科学数据和临床经验相结合,达成共识声明。
一项修改后的德尔菲研究,旨在基于来自 17 个国家的 55 名多学科专家的科学数据和临床经验相结合,达成共识。专家们被要求对一系列关于治疗儿童期 ADHD 对青少年 SUD 的影响以及对共患 ADHD 和 SUD 的青少年进行筛查、诊断和治疗的陈述进行评分。
经过 3 轮迭代评分和调整 37 个陈述,就其中 36 个陈述达成共识,这些陈述代表了 6 个领域:一般(n=4)、发生 SUD 的风险(n=3)、筛查和诊断(n=7)、心理社会治疗(n=5)、药物治疗(n=11)和补充治疗(n=7)。建议在物质滥用治疗中的青少年患者中常规筛查 ADHD,在精神保健机构中的 ADHD 青少年患者中筛查 SUD。长效兴奋剂被推荐作为共患 ADHD 和 SUD 的青少年 ADHD 的一线治疗药物,药物治疗最好嵌入心理社会治疗中。唯一未达成共识的陈述涉及在开始治疗 ADHD 青少年和共患 SUD 之前是否需要戒除物质。与大多数专家不同,一些专家要求在开始任何药物治疗之前完全戒除物质,一些专家反对在这些患者中使用兴奋剂(无论是否戒除物质),而另一些专家则反对替代使用安非他酮。
本国际共识声明可由临床医生和患者共同在共同决策过程中使用,以选择最佳干预措施,并使共患 ADHD 和 SUD 的青少年患者达到最佳治疗效果。