Di Gennaro Salvatore Filippo, Matese Alessandro
Institute of BioEconomy, National Research Council (CNR-IBE), Via G. Caproni, 8, 50145 Florence, Italy.
Plant Methods. 2020 Jul 3;16:91. doi: 10.1186/s13007-020-00632-2. eCollection 2020.
The knowledge of vine vegetative status within a vineyard plays a key role in canopy management in order to achieve a correct vine balance and reach the final desired yield/quality. Detailed information about canopy architecture and missing plants distribution provides useful support for farmers/winegrowers to optimize canopy management practices and the replanting process, respectively. In the last decade, there has been a progressive diffusion of UAV (Unmanned Aerial Vehicles) technologies for Precision Viticulture purposes, as fast and accurate methodologies for spatial variability of geometric plant parameters. The aim of this study was to implement an unsupervised and integrated procedure of biomass estimation and missing plants detection, using both the 2.5D-surface and 3D-alphashape methods.
Both methods showed good overall accuracy respect to ground truth biomass measurements with high values of R (0.71 and 0.80 for 2.5D and 3D, respectively). The 2.5D method led to an overestimation since it is derived by considering the vine as rectangular cuboid form. On the contrary, the 3D method provided more accurate results as a consequence of the alphashape algorithm, which is capable to detect each single shoot and holes within the canopy. Regarding the missing plants detection, the 3D approach confirmed better performance in cases of hidden conditions by shoots of adjacent plants or sparse canopy with some empty spaces along the row, where the 2.5D method based on the length of section of the row with lower thickness than the threshold used (0.10 m), tended to return false negatives and false positives, respectively.
This paper describes a rapid and objective tool for the farmer to promptly identify canopy management strategies and drive replanting decisions. The 3D approach provided results closer to real canopy volume and higher performance in missing plant detection. However, the dense cloud based analysis required more processing time. In a future perspective, given the continuous technological evolution in terms of computing performance, the overcoming of the current limit represented by the pre- and post-processing phases of the large image dataset should mainstream this methodology.
了解葡萄园藤蔓的营养状况对于树冠管理起着关键作用,以便实现藤蔓的正确平衡并达到最终期望的产量/质量。有关树冠结构和缺失植株分布的详细信息分别为农民/葡萄种植者优化树冠管理实践和重新种植过程提供了有用的支持。在过去十年中,无人机(无人驾驶飞行器)技术为精准葡萄种植目的而逐渐普及,成为获取几何植物参数空间变异性的快速且准确的方法。本研究的目的是使用2.5D表面和3D阿尔法形状方法实施一种无监督的综合生物量估计和缺失植株检测程序。
两种方法相对于地面真实生物量测量均显示出良好的总体准确性,R值较高(2.5D和3D分别为0.71和0.80)。2.5D方法导致高估,因为它是通过将藤蔓视为长方体形式得出的。相反,由于阿尔法形状算法能够检测树冠内的每个单枝和空洞,3D方法提供了更准确的结果。关于缺失植株检测,在相邻植株的枝条隐藏条件下或沿行有一些空隙的稀疏树冠情况下,3D方法表现出更好的性能,而基于行段长度且厚度低于所用阈值(0.10米)的2.5D方法往往分别返回假阴性和假阳性结果。
本文描述了一种快速且客观的工具,可帮助农民迅速确定树冠管理策略并推动重新种植决策。3D方法提供的结果更接近实际树冠体积,并且在缺失植株检测方面性能更高。然而,基于密集点云的分析需要更多处理时间。从未来角度看,鉴于计算性能方面的持续技术发展,克服当前由大型图像数据集的预处理和后处理阶段所代表的限制应使该方法成为主流。