Divisions of Audiology and Vestibular Sciences, Vanderbilt University Medical Center, Nashville, TN.
Am J Audiol. 2020 Sep 3;29(3):410-418. doi: 10.1044/2020_AJA-19-00119. Epub 2020 Jul 13.
Purpose The purpose of the current investigation was to determine the interrelations among vestibular disorders from a data set generated from the patient perspective as compared to previous data generated from the physician's perspective. Method The data for the current investigation originated from a previously published study describing the development of the Dizziness Symptom Profile (DSP; Jacobson et al., 2019). The DSP is a 31-item patient self-report tool designed to help primary care physicians in the development of a differential diagnosis using the patient's level of agreement with each dizziness and symptom-related statement. Responses to these items converge on common vestibular diagnoses and were previously found to agree with ear specialist differential diagnoses 70.3% of the time. Data were collected for 131 subjects ( = 56.7 years, 72 women) seen for evaluation in a tertiary dizziness specialty clinic. For this study, the data were analyzed using descriptive statistics to determine the frequency of single diagnoses, multiple diagnoses, co-occurring diagnoses, and patterns of co-occurrence. Results Results indicated that 52.7% of patients endorsed a single vestibular diagnosis and 47.3% endorsed two or more vestibular diagnoses. Benign paroxysmal positional vertigo (BPPV) and vestibular migraine were the most common single diagnoses and also the most common co-occurring diagnoses. As the number of diagnoses endorsed on the DSP increased, so did the percentage of time that BPPV and vestibular migraine would occur. Conclusions Results support and extend the work of others but using data generated from the perspective of the patient. A slight majority of patients endorsed a single disorder, but almost as many patients endorsed more than one vestibular diagnosis. BPPV and vestibular migraine were the most common single vestibular diagnoses and also the most common co-occurring vestibular diagnoses; vestibular migraine was more common when multiple diagnoses were endorsed. Results suggest it is common for patients to volunteer symptoms that cannot be explained by a single vestibular diagnosis. This finding is in agreement with physician-generated diagnosis data. Clinicians should consider the possibility of co-occurring diagnoses in complicated patients or in patients who are not responding optimally to management of a single vestibular disorder. The DSP is a tool that encourages clinicians to consider multiple co-occurring vestibular disorders as the source of patient complaints.
目的 本研究旨在从患者角度生成的数据集与以往从医生角度生成的数据相比,确定前庭障碍之间的相互关系。
方法 本研究的数据来自先前发表的一项研究,该研究描述了眩晕症状特征(DSP;Jacobson 等人,2019 年)的发展。DSP 是一种 31 项患者自我报告工具,旨在帮助初级保健医生根据患者对每个眩晕和与症状相关的陈述的一致程度进行鉴别诊断。这些项目的回答集中在常见的前庭诊断上,并且之前发现与耳科专家的鉴别诊断一致的比例为 70.3%。为这项研究收集了 131 名受试者的数据(=56.7 岁,72 名女性),这些受试者在三级眩晕专科诊所接受评估。本研究使用描述性统计数据分析数据,以确定单一诊断、多种诊断、同时发生的诊断以及同时发生的模式的频率。
结果 结果表明,52.7%的患者认可单一的前庭诊断,而 47.3%的患者认可两种或更多的前庭诊断。良性阵发性位置性眩晕(BPPV)和前庭性偏头痛是最常见的单一诊断,也是最常见的同时发生的诊断。随着 DSP 上认可的诊断数量的增加,BPPV 和前庭性偏头痛发生的时间百分比也会增加。
结论 结果支持并扩展了其他人的工作,但使用的是从患者角度生成的数据。大多数患者认可单一疾病,但几乎同样多的患者认可多种前庭诊断。BPPV 和前庭性偏头痛是最常见的单一前庭诊断,也是最常见的同时发生的前庭诊断;当认可多种诊断时,更常见的是前庭性偏头痛。结果表明,患者自愿报告无法用单一前庭诊断解释的症状很常见。这一发现与医生生成的诊断数据一致。临床医生应考虑在复杂患者或对单一前庭疾病管理反应不佳的患者中同时存在多种诊断的可能性。DSP 是一种鼓励临床医生将多种同时发生的前庭疾病视为患者抱怨的来源的工具。