The University of Edinburgh Medical School, Chancellors Building, 49 Little France Crescent, Edinburgh, Scotland, UK.
Department of Clinical Surgery, Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh, NHS Lothian, Scotland, UK.
Surgeon. 2020 Dec;18(6):e39-e46. doi: 10.1016/j.surge.2020.06.007. Epub 2020 Jul 15.
The constant pressure facing hospitals to reduce emergency inpatient admissions has led towards more consultant-led 'Hot Clinics' (HC). The patient experience in these settings remains poorly understood. This study evaluates the efficiency and ability of the HC to prevent unnecessary emergency surgical admissions and factors influencing the patient experience.
Patients were referred to the HC from the Emergency Department, General Practice or Out-of-Hours service over the initial six-week period. A questionnaire collected the reason for referral, management without a HC, final diagnosis and management. Appropriateness of referrals were evaluated by the HC consultant and retrospectively by a blinded consultant. A second questionnaire collected information on patient satisfaction in a subsequent study period.
119/126 referrals (94%) were judged appropriate in the HC analysis with 97/126 (77%) considered appropriate in the retrospective analysis. The HC reduced the amount of potential emergency surgical admissions from 114 to 14 (p < 0.001). In the second period, 114/121 patients (94%) rated the HC as very good or good; with privacy (p < 0.05) and decision-making (p < 0.001) linked to patient satisfaction. Comfort (p < 0.05) and decision-making (p < 0.001) were linked to patients recommending the service. 103 patients (85%) would be extremely, or very likely to recommend the HC service with 93 patients (77%) preferring HC treatment over a hospital admission.
Most referrals to the HC were appropriate and it continues to prevent unnecessary emergency surgical admissions. The HC service is valued by NHS patients, who prefer HC treatment over admission. Various factors to improve the patient experience in HC have been identified.
医院面临着减少急诊住院人数的持续压力,这导致了更多由顾问主导的“热门诊所”(HC)的出现。这些环境中的患者体验仍然知之甚少。本研究评估了 HC 预防不必要的急诊手术入院的效率和能力,以及影响患者体验的因素。
在最初的六周内,患者从急诊科、全科医生或非工作时间服务转介到 HC。一份问卷收集了转诊的原因、没有 HC 的管理、最终诊断和管理。HC 顾问对转诊的适宜性进行了评估,并由一名盲法顾问进行了回顾性评估。第二份问卷在随后的研究期间收集了患者满意度的信息。
在 HC 分析中,119/126 例(94%)转诊被认为是合适的,而在回顾性分析中,97/126 例(77%)被认为是合适的。HC 将潜在的急诊手术入院人数从 114 例减少到 14 例(p<0.001)。在第二阶段,114/121 例(94%)患者对 HC 的评价非常好或好;隐私(p<0.05)和决策(p<0.001)与患者满意度相关。舒适度(p<0.05)和决策(p<0.001)与患者推荐该服务有关。103 例(85%)患者非常或极有可能推荐 HC 服务,93 例(77%)患者更喜欢 HC 治疗而非住院治疗。
大多数转介到 HC 的患者都是合适的,并且它继续预防不必要的急诊手术入院。NHS 患者非常重视 HC 服务,他们更喜欢 HC 治疗而不是住院治疗。已经确定了各种提高 HC 患者体验的因素。