Department of Applied Mathematics, State University of Campinas, General Hospital of the Medicine School of University of São Paulo, Campinas, Brazil.
Division of Allergy and Immunology, General Hospital of the Medicine School of University of São Paulo, Campinas, Brazil.
Epidemiol Infect. 2020 Jul 20;148:e155. doi: 10.1017/S0950268820001600.
In São Paulo, Brazil, the first case of coronavirus disease 2019 (CoViD-19) was confirmed on 26 February, the first death due to CoViD-19 was registered on 16 March, and on 24 March, São Paulo implemented the isolation of persons in non-essential activities. A mathematical model was formulated based on non-linear ordinary differential equations considering young (60 years old or less) and elder (60 years old or more) subpopulations, aiming to describe the introduction and dissemination of the new coronavirus in São Paulo. This deterministic model used the data collected from São Paulo to estimate the model parameters, obtaining R0 = 6.8 for the basic reproduction number. The model also allowed to estimate that 50% of the population of São Paulo was in isolation, which permitted to describe the current epidemiological status. The goal of isolation implemented in São Paulo to control the rapid increase of the new coronavirus epidemic was partially succeeded, concluding that if isolation of at least 80% of the population had been implemented, the collapse in the health care system could be avoided. Nevertheless, the isolated persons must be released one day. Based on this model, we studied the potential epidemiological scenarios of release by varying the proportions of the release of young and elder persons. We also evaluated three different strategies of release: All isolated persons are released simultaneously, two and three releases divided in equal proportions. The better scenarios occurred when young persons are released, but maintaining elder persons isolated for a while. When compared with the epidemic without isolation, all strategies of release did not attain the goal of reducing substantially the number of hospitalisations due to severe CoViD-19. Hence, we concluded that the best decision must be postponing the beginning of the release.
在巴西圣保罗,2019 年冠状病毒病(CoViD-19)的首例病例于 2 月 26 日确诊,首例 CoViD-19 死亡病例于 3 月 16 日登记,3 月 24 日,圣保罗开始实施非必要活动人员隔离。本研究建立了一个基于考虑年轻(60 岁或以下)和老年(60 岁或以上)亚人群的非线性常微分方程的数学模型,旨在描述新型冠状病毒在圣保罗的引入和传播。该确定性模型使用从圣保罗收集的数据来估计模型参数,得到基本繁殖数 R0 = 6.8。该模型还估计了圣保罗 50%的人口处于隔离状态,这允许描述当前的流行病学状况。为控制新型冠状病毒疫情的快速蔓延而在圣保罗实施的隔离目标部分取得了成功,得出的结论是,如果至少 80%的人口实施隔离,就可以避免医疗保健系统崩溃。然而,隔离人员终有一天会被释放。基于这个模型,我们通过改变年轻和老年人口释放比例来研究释放的潜在流行病学情景。我们还评估了三种不同的释放策略:所有隔离人员同时释放、两批和三批等比例释放。当年轻人群释放时,情况会更好,但同时老年人群也需要隔离一段时间。与无隔离的疫情相比,所有释放策略都没有达到大幅减少因严重 CoViD-19 住院人数的目标。因此,我们得出的结论是,推迟释放的开始是最好的决定。