Adesanya Adedoyin Adekunle
Department of Surgery, College of Medicine, University of Lagos; Lagos University Teaching Hospital, Idi-Araba; Journal Unit, National Postgraduate Medical College of Nigeria, Ijanikin, Lagos, Nigeria.
Niger Postgrad Med J. 2020 Jul-Sep;27(3):250-258. doi: 10.4103/npmj.npmj_51_20.
Research misconduct policy (RMP) is a legal document that shows the definitions of the various types of misconduct, describes the inquiry and investigation of allegations, and the appropriate penalties that should be imposed. The presence of the adopted RMP on the website of a university or postgraduate college is an indication of the level of commitment to promote the proper handling of misconduct cases. Perusal of the websites of top universities in developing countries revealed that many do not have RMP on their websites. The probable starting point for combating research misconduct at the national or institutional level is by acquisition of RMP. The purpose of this article is to propose a modern, structured and cost-effective RMP for universities and postgraduate colleges in developing countries. The bibliographic database, PubMed, was searched using the terms 'research misconduct' and 'research misconduct policy'. All relevant articles from the search and some RMPs of universities, national agencies and global health organisations available on the Internet were carefully studied. A formulated RMP, based on the Final Rule of the United States, Public Health Services Policies on Research Misconduct of 2005 and the Regulations of the University Grants Commission of India of 2018, is hereby presented. In the proposed RMP, plagiarism was stratified into four levels in ascending order of severity so that imposed penalties are commensurate with the seriousness of misconduct. The zero tolerance for plagiarism in the core work areas was adopted. The proposed RMP was designed to act as a template. It should be modified as required based on the prevailing local circumstances and made fit for purpose. Universities, postgraduate colleges and journals should have RMP on the homepage of their websites.
研究不当行为政策(RMP)是一份法律文件,它给出了各类不当行为的定义,描述了对指控的调查询问以及应施加的适当处罚。大学或研究生学院网站上有已采用的RMP表明其在推动妥善处理不当行为案件方面的投入程度。查阅发展中国家顶尖大学的网站发现,许多大学网站上没有RMP。在国家或机构层面打击研究不当行为的可能起点是获取RMP。本文的目的是为发展中国家的大学和研究生学院提出一个现代、结构化且具有成本效益的RMP。使用“研究不当行为”和“研究不当行为政策”等术语在文献数据库PubMed中进行了检索。对检索到的所有相关文章以及互联网上可获取的一些大学、国家机构和全球卫生组织的RMP进行了仔细研究。在此呈现一个基于美国2005年《公共卫生服务研究不当行为政策最终规则》和印度大学资助委员会2018年《条例》制定的RMP。在所提议的RMP中,抄袭行为按严重程度升序分为四个级别,以便所施加的处罚与不当行为的严重程度相称。在核心工作领域采用了对抄袭行为零容忍的规定。所提议的RMP旨在作为一个模板。应根据当地实际情况进行必要修改,使其符合目的。大学、研究生学院和期刊应在其网站首页设有RMP。