Haringey Learning Disability Partnership, Barnet, Enfield and Haringey Mental Health NHS Trust , London, UK.
Cornwall Partnership NHS Foundation Trust, Threemilestone Industrial Estate Truro , Truro, England, UK.
Expert Opin Pharmacother. 2020 Oct;21(15):1897-1913. doi: 10.1080/14656566.2020.1790524. Epub 2020 Jul 21.
ADHD causes significant distress and functional impairment in multiple domains of daily life. Therefore, diagnosis and treatment are important to improve the quality of life of people. The pharmacotherapy for ADHD is well established but needs systematic evaluation in Intellectual Disability (ID) populations.
This paper reviews the ADHD pharmacological treatment in people with ID using the PRISMA guidance for scoping reviews to help identify the nature and strength of evidence.
In the last 20 years, seven randomized controlled trials have evaluated pharmacotherapies for ADHD in people with ID; five looking at methylphenidate. Generally, studies were underpowered; all but two had less than 25 participants. Of the two larger trials one was single blinded and therefore open to bias. Only two used a parallel-group method, the remainder were mostly short crossover trials; not ideal when measuring behavioral and psychological parameters which are long standing. The remaining evidence is made up of observational studies. Methylphenidate and atomoxetine, particularly at higher doses, have shown clear benefits in people with ID. Most people with ID tolerated ADHD medications well. Benefits were seen in behavioral and/or cognitive domains. The evidence base is limited, though promising, for dexamfetamine, clonidine, and guanfacine.
ADHD 会在日常生活的多个领域造成明显的痛苦和功能障碍。因此,诊断和治疗对于提高人们的生活质量非常重要。ADHD 的药物治疗已经得到很好的确立,但在智力障碍 (ID) 人群中需要进行系统评估。
本文使用 PRISMA 指导进行范围审查,回顾了 ID 人群中 ADHD 的药物治疗,以帮助确定证据的性质和强度。
在过去的 20 年里,已经有七项随机对照试验评估了 ID 人群中 ADHD 的药物治疗;其中五项研究了哌醋甲酯。一般来说,这些研究的样本量不足;除了两项研究外,其余研究的参与者都少于 25 人。在两项较大的试验中,一项为单盲,因此容易存在偏倚。只有两项研究采用了平行组方法,其余研究大多是短期交叉试验;对于测量行为和心理参数等长期存在的问题,这并不理想。其余的证据由观察性研究组成。哌醋甲酯和托莫西汀,特别是高剂量时,在 ID 人群中显示出明显的益处。大多数 ID 患者对 ADHD 药物的耐受性良好。在行为和/或认知领域都观察到了益处。虽然有希望,但去甲伪麻黄碱、可乐定和胍法辛的证据基础有限。