University of Bolton, Bolton, United Kingdom.
PLoS One. 2020 Jul 23;15(7):e0235157. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0235157. eCollection 2020.
What factors determine success at University? For many years the construct of intelligence was felt to be critical. More recently, the construct of grit, has attracted the attention of many researchers, along with related concepts such as self-control, growth mind-sets and resilience. The authors of this paper have developed a specific measure of tenacity and self-composure, two constructs crucial to academic achievement. This measure comprises of 12 items drawn from the above constructs, but also including mental well-being and strengths use. In the first study, the authors report on the psychometric properties of the Bolton Uni-Stride Scale (BUSS). The new scale was administered to 1117 university students. Exploratory factor analysis (EFA) revealed two underlying factors, one labelled "tenacity" had seven items and accounted for 30% of the variance. The second was labelled "self-composure," and accounted for 14% of the variance. In the second study the BUSS was given to 340 undergraduate students along with the Grit Scale, the Self-Control Scale, the Mind-sets Quiz, the Connor Davidson Resilience Scale (CD-RISC 10) and the short Warwick Edinburgh Mental Well-being Scale (WEMWBS). This study presented evidence for good internal consistency reliability (.74) and test-retest reliability over three weeks was .70 for Tenacity and .77 for Self-composure. BUSS Academic Tenacity correlated highly with grit (.63), self-control (.59), resilience (.52), mind-sets (.35) and mental well-being (.54). The study also evidences good discriminative validity of the BUSS. A second study conducted confirmatory factor analysis (CFA), explaining a total of 44% of the variance. The authors have shown good support for the reliability and validity of the BUSS scale. It now needs to be tested in other universities and in different countries. It is the contention of the authors that academic tenacity will be a better measure of academic success than other competing measures, such as grit, on their own. Further research is needed to test this assertion.
是什么因素决定了一个人在大学的成功?多年来,人们一直认为智力结构是至关重要的。最近,坚毅等相关概念,如自我控制、成长心态和适应力,引起了许多研究人员的关注。本文作者开发了一种衡量坚韧和自我镇定的特定方法,这两个结构对学业成绩至关重要。该方法由 12 个项目组成,这些项目来自于上述结构,但也包括心理健康和优势利用。在第一项研究中,作者报告了 Bolton Uni-Stride 量表(BUSS)的心理测量学特性。新量表被施测于 1117 名大学生。探索性因素分析(EFA)揭示了两个潜在的因素,一个被标记为“坚韧”,包含 7 个项目,占方差的 30%。第二个被标记为“自我镇定”,占方差的 14%。在第二项研究中,340 名本科生接受了 BUSS 量表、坚毅量表、自我控制量表、心态测验、Connor-Davidson 适应力量表(CD-RISC 10)和 Warwick-Edinburgh 心理健康量表(WEMWBS)的测试。该研究表明,该量表具有良好的内部一致性信度(.74),坚韧维度的重测信度为 3 周时的.70,自我镇定维度的重测信度为.77。BUSS 学术坚韧与坚毅(.63)、自我控制(.59)、适应力(.52)、心态(.35)和心理健康(.54)高度相关。该研究还证明了 BUSS 具有良好的区分效度。第二项研究进行了验证性因素分析(CFA),解释了总方差的 44%。作者已经很好地支持了 BUSS 量表的可靠性和有效性。现在需要在其他大学和不同国家进行测试。作者认为,学术坚韧将是比其他竞争指标(如坚毅)更好的衡量学术成功的指标。需要进一步的研究来验证这一说法。