Gebhardt Jordan T, Woodworth Jason C, Tokach Mike D, DeRouchey Joel M, Goodband Robert D, Loughmiller Joe A, de Souza Ana L P, Dritz Steve S
Department of Animal Sciences and Industry, College of Agriculture, Kansas State University, Manhattan, KS.
Kemin Industries, Des Moines, IA.
Transl Anim Sci. 2018 Oct 11;3(1):384-392. doi: 10.1093/tas/txy104. eCollection 2019 Jan.
Although chromium (Cr) feeding study results have been variable, our hypothesis was feeding a regimen that changed dosage over time would result in a larger positive response in growth performance and carcass characteristics. In Exp. 1, a total of 1,206 pigs (PIC 337 × 1050, initial BW 28.7 kg) were used with 27 pigs per pen and 9 pens per treatment. Diets were corn-soybean meal-dried distillers grains with solubles based and were fed in a five-phase feeding program. Treatments were arranged as a 2 × 2 + 1 factorial with a control diet containing no added Cr propionate (Kemin Industries Inc., Des Moines, IA), or diets with either 100 or 200 µg/kg added Cr during the grower (dietary phases 1 and 2) and/or finisher (dietary phases 3, 4, and 5) periods. During the grower period, ADG and G:F were similar among pigs fed the control or 100 µg/kg added Cr diets, but decreased in pigs fed 200 µg/kg Cr (quadratic, ≤ 0.001). During the finisher period, pigs supplemented with 200 µg/kg added Cr had the greatest ADG and G:F (quadratic, ≤ 0.019). Overall, increasing Cr had no effect on ADG or ADFI; but G:F was greatest (quadratic, = 0.020) when pigs were fed 100 µg/kg of added Cr throughout. Carcass characteristics were not influenced by Cr dosage or feeding regimen. In Exp. 2, a total of 1,206 pigs (PIC 359 × 1050, initial BW 48.9 kg) were used with 27 pigs per pen and 15 pens per treatment. Diets were corn-soybean meal, dried distillers grains with solubles based and were fed in four phases. There were three dietary treatments: a diet with no added Cr for both grower (dietary phase 1 and 2) and finisher (dietary phase 3 and 4) periods, a diet with 200 µg/kg added Cr during the grower and 100 µg/kg added Cr during the finisher periods, or a diet with 200 µg/kg added Cr for both periods. Addition of 200 µg/kg Cr in both periods marginally increased ( < 0.10) ADG compared with pigs fed no added Cr. There was no evidence ( ≥ 0.523) of added Cr influencing overall ADFI and G:F. Percentage carcass yield was reduced ( = 0.018) when Cr was added at 200 µg/kg for both periods, with no evidence of differences ( ≥ 0.206) in other carcass characteristics. In summary, overall G:F was improved in Exp. 1, and ADG in Exp. 2, by added Cr, but there was no evidence that different feeding regimens will consistently result in improved performance. However, these data are consistent with the literature in that added Cr in growing-finishing pigs diets improves, albeit small, ADG or G:F.
尽管铬(Cr)饲喂研究结果存在差异,但我们的假设是,采用随时间变化剂量的饲喂方案会使生长性能和胴体特性产生更大的正向反应。在试验1中,总共使用了1206头猪(PIC 337×1050,初始体重28.7千克),每栏27头猪,每个处理9栏。日粮以玉米-豆粕-干酒糟及其可溶物为基础,并采用五阶段饲喂程序。处理按2×2 + 1析因设计,对照日粮不添加丙酸铬(Kemin Industries Inc.,得梅因,爱荷华州),或在生长育肥期(日粮阶段1和2)和/或育肥期(日粮阶段3、4和5)添加100或200微克/千克铬的日粮。在生长育肥期,饲喂对照日粮或添加100微克/千克铬日粮的猪的平均日增重(ADG)和料重比(G:F)相似,但饲喂200微克/千克铬的猪的ADG和G:F下降(二次效应,P≤0.001)。在育肥期,添加200微克/千克铬的猪的ADG和G:F最大(二次效应,P≤0.019)。总体而言,增加铬对ADG或平均日采食量(ADFI)没有影响;但当猪全程饲喂100微克/千克添加铬时,G:F最大(二次效应,P = 0.020)。胴体特性不受铬剂量或饲喂方案的影响。在试验2中,总共使用了1206头猪(PIC 359×1050,初始体重48.9千克),每栏27头猪,每个处理15栏。日粮以玉米-豆粕-干酒糟及其可溶物为基础,并采用四阶段饲喂。有三种日粮处理:生长育肥期(日粮阶段1和2以及日粮阶段3和4)均不添加铬的日粮、生长育肥期添加200微克/千克铬且育肥期添加100微克/千克铬的日粮,或两个时期均添加200微克/千克铬的日粮。与不添加铬的猪相比,两个时期均添加200微克/千克铬略微提高了(P<0.10)ADG。没有证据(P≥0.523)表明添加铬会影响总体ADFI和G:F。当两个时期均添加200微克/千克铬时,胴体产率百分比降低(P = 0.018),其他胴体特性没有差异证据(P≥0.206)。总之,在试验1中总体G:F得到改善,在试验2中ADG得到改善,这是添加铬的结果,但没有证据表明不同的饲喂方案会持续提高生产性能。然而,这些数据与文献一致,即生长育肥猪日粮中添加铬可提高ADG或G:F,尽管增幅较小。