Schirrmacher Volker, Sprenger Tobias, Stuecker Wilfried, Van Gool Stefaan W
Immune-Oncological Center Cologne (IOZK), D-50674 Cologne, Germany.
Biomedicines. 2020 Jul 23;8(8):237. doi: 10.3390/biomedicines8080237.
At times of personalized and individualized medicine the concept of randomized- controlled clinical trials (RCTs) is being questioned. This review article explains principles of evidence-based medicine in oncology and shows an example of how evidence can be generated independently from RCTs. Personalized medicine involves molecular analysis of tumor properties and targeted therapy with small molecule inhibitors. Individualized medicine involves the whole patient (tumor and host) in the context of immunotherapy. The example is called Individualized Multimodal Immunotherapy (IMI). It is based on the individuality of immunological tumor-host interactions and on the concept of immunogenic tumor cell death (ICD) induced by an oncolytic virus. The evidence is generated by systematic data collection and analysis. The outcome is then shared with the scientific and medical community. The priority of big pharma studies is commercial benefit. Methods used to achieve this are described and have damaged the image of RCT studies in general. A critical discussion is recommended between all partners of the medical health system with regard to the conduct of RCTs by big pharma companies. Several clinics and institutions in Europe try to become more independent from pharma industry and to develop their own modern cancer therapeutics. Medical associations should include references to such studies from personalized and individualized medicine in their guidelines.
在个性化和个体化医疗时代,随机对照临床试验(RCT)的概念正受到质疑。这篇综述文章解释了肿瘤学中循证医学的原则,并展示了一个如何独立于RCT生成证据的例子。个性化医疗涉及肿瘤特性的分子分析和小分子抑制剂的靶向治疗。个体化医疗在免疫治疗背景下涉及整个患者(肿瘤和宿主)。这个例子称为个体化多模式免疫疗法(IMI)。它基于免疫肿瘤 - 宿主相互作用的个体性以及溶瘤病毒诱导的免疫原性肿瘤细胞死亡(ICD)的概念。证据通过系统的数据收集和分析生成。然后将结果与科学界和医学界分享。大型制药公司研究的首要目标是商业利益。文中描述了用于实现这一目标的方法,这些方法总体上损害了RCT研究的形象。建议医疗卫生系统的所有合作伙伴就大型制药公司进行的RCT的实施展开批判性讨论。欧洲的几家诊所和机构试图减少对制药行业的依赖,并开发自己的现代癌症治疗方法。医学协会应在其指南中纳入来自个性化和个体化医疗此类研究的参考文献。