Necknig Ulrike H, Wolff Ingmar, Bründl Johannes, Kriegmair Maximilian C, Marghawal David, Wagener Nina, Hegemann Miriam, Eder Elisabeth, Wülfing Christian, Burger Maximilian, Leyh Herbert, May Matthias, Kiesewetter Jan, Weidenbusch Marc
Klinikum Garmisch-Partenkirchen GmbH, Abteilung für Urologie & Kinderurologie, Garmisch-Partenkirchen.
Universitätsmedizin Greifswald, Klinik und Poliklinik für Urologie, Greifswald.
Aktuelle Urol. 2022 Aug;53(4):331-342. doi: 10.1055/a-1194-3611. Epub 2020 Jul 28.
Urological senior physicians in Germany are a heterogeneous group with various clinical priorities and career objectives. To date, there are no reliable data concerning the impact of the time span for which senior physicians have been holding their position on professional, personal and position-linked aspects.
The objective of this study was a comparative analysis of perspectives, private and professional settings, specific job-related activities and individual professional goals of urological senior physicians in Germany based on their experience in this position assessed as number of years (dichotomised at 8 years as senior physician). As part of a cross-sectional study, a 55-item web-based questionnaire was designed, which was sent via a link to members of a mailing list of the German Society of Urology. The survey was available for urological senior physicians between February and April 2019. Group differences were evaluated using multivariate regression models.
107 of 192 evaluable questionnaires were completed by senior physicians holding this position for less than 8 years (< 8y senior physicians), 85 were completed by senior physicians holding this position for at least 8 years (≥ 8y senior physicians). < 8y senior physicians worked significantly more often at university hospitals (42.1 % vs. 18.8 %, p = 0.002). Overall, 82.4 % of ≥ 8y senior physicians assessed themselves autonomously safe in performing open surgery, compared to 39.3 % among < 8y senior physicians (p < 0.001). No significant differences concerning the self-assessment were found for endourological procedures (94.1 % vs. 87.9 %) and for the overall lower-rated self-assessment concerning laparoscopy (29.4 % vs. 20.6 %) and robotic surgery (14.1 % vs. 10.3 %). Despite the high management responsibility associated with their position, only about one third of participants (34.8 %) had received specific postgraduate education preparing them for managing and executive tasks.
This study shows significant differences among senior physicians regarding surgical skills depending on the time span they hold their position. Moreover, there is considerable dissatisfaction regarding the development of leadership skills and the preparation for managing tasks. In order to ensure availability of senior staff members for the field of urology in the future, it is important to consider their professional needs and to overcome existing shortcomings by education programs within well-orchestrated human resources development strategies.
德国泌尿外科高级医师是一个异质性群体,有着不同的临床重点和职业目标。迄今为止,尚无可靠数据表明高级医师担任该职位的时长对其职业、个人及职位相关方面的影响。
本研究的目的是基于德国泌尿外科高级医师担任该职位的年限(以8年为界分为两组),对其观点、私人及职业背景、特定的与工作相关的活动以及个人职业目标进行比较分析。作为一项横断面研究的一部分,设计了一份包含55个条目的网络问卷,并通过链接发送给德国泌尿外科学会邮件列表的成员。该调查于2019年2月至4月面向泌尿外科高级医师开展。使用多元回归模型评估组间差异。
192份可评估问卷中,107份由担任该职位不到8年的高级医师完成(<8年高级医师),85份由担任该职位至少8年的高级医师完成(≥8年高级医师)。<8年高级医师在大学医院工作的频率显著更高(42.1%对18.8%,p = 0.002)。总体而言,82.4%的≥8年高级医师认为自己在进行开放手术时自主操作安全,而<8年高级医师中这一比例为39.3%(p < 0.001)。在内窥镜手术方面(94.1%对87.9%)以及腹腔镜手术(29.4%对20.6%)和机器人手术(14.1%对10.3%)的总体自我评估较低方面,未发现自我评估存在显著差异。尽管其职位伴随着较高的管理职责,但只有约三分之一的参与者(34.8%)接受过为管理和执行任务做准备的特定研究生教育。
本研究表明,高级医师在手术技能方面存在显著差异,这取决于他们担任该职位的时长。此外,在领导技能发展和管理任务准备方面存在相当大的不满。为确保未来泌尿外科领域有高级工作人员可用,重要的是考虑他们的职业需求,并通过精心策划的人力资源发展战略中的教育项目克服现有不足。