Nardi Paolo, Pisano Calogera, Altieri Claudia, Buioni Dario, Pedicelli Carlo, Saulle Silvia, Dandi Romana, Romano Alessia, Servadio Annamaria, Gianlorenzi Alessandra, Emili Katia, Ruvolo Giovanni
Cardiac Surgery Division, Tor Vergata University Hospital, Rome, Italy.
Degree of Physiotherapy, Tor Vergata University Hospital, Rome, Italy.
Kardiochir Torakochirurgia Pol. 2020 Jun;17(2):94-100. doi: 10.5114/kitp.2020.97267. Epub 2020 Jul 20.
Loss of physical activity and pulmonary dysfunction with its associated complications represent two of the most important causes of morbidity and mortality following cardiac surgery.
To evaluate whether a physiotherapy program based on respiratory training with or without musculoskeletal mobilization, started preoperatively, may provide a significant improvement in pulmonary and musculoskeletal recovery postoperatively in a sufficiently large sample of patients undergoing elective cardiac surgery.
One-hundred and two patients with similar baseline and preoperative characteristics were assigned to a preoperative respiratory physiotherapy protocol (group R, = 34), a preoperative respiratory and motor physiotherapy protocol (group R + M, = 34), or no preoperative specific physiotherapy protocol but only a simplified perioperative standard physiotherapy protocol (control group, C, = 34). Data on 6-minute walking test, peak expiratory flow, and from blood gas analysis were retrospectively analyzed.
As compared with group C, a statistically significant improvement was observed in the two preoperatively treated groups in terms of 1) better pre- (+0.7-0.8 Lt/min, < 0.05) and postoperative (+1 Lt/min, < 0.01) peak expiratory flow values; 2) longer pre- (+50-100 m, < 0.01) and postoperative (+65-170 m, < 0.01) distance traveled in the 6-minute walking test; 3) better PaO, SaO, pH value in postoperative blood gas measurements ( < 0.05, for all comparisons); 4) reduction of postoperative length of in-hospital stay ( < 0.05).
A benefit of combined respiratory and motor physiotherapy protocols can be expected in the groups of patients preoperatively treated, especially with the respiratory one, either before or after cardiac surgery with a faster recovery of physical-functional activities. Specifically, the motor protocol is associated with greater autonomy of running before or after cardiac surgery.
体力活动丧失和肺功能障碍及其相关并发症是心脏手术后发病和死亡的两个最重要原因。
评估术前开始的基于呼吸训练(有或无肌肉骨骼活动)的物理治疗方案是否能在足够大样本的择期心脏手术患者中显著改善术后肺和肌肉骨骼的恢复情况。
102例具有相似基线和术前特征的患者被分配到术前呼吸物理治疗方案组(R组,n = 34)、术前呼吸和运动物理治疗方案组(R + M组,n = 34)或无术前特定物理治疗方案但仅有简化围手术期标准物理治疗方案的对照组(C组,n = 34)。对6分钟步行试验、呼气峰值流速和血气分析数据进行回顾性分析。
与C组相比,两个术前治疗组在以下方面观察到统计学上的显著改善:1)术前(+0.7 - 0.8升/分钟,P < 0.05)和术后(+1升/分钟,P < 0.01)呼气峰值流速值更好;2)6分钟步行试验中术前(+50 - 100米,P < 0.01)和术后(+65 - 170米,P < 0.01)行走距离更长;3)术后血气测量中PaO、SaO、pH值更好(所有比较P < 0.05);4)术后住院时间缩短(P < 0.05)。
术前接受治疗的患者组,尤其是接受呼吸物理治疗的患者组,有望从呼吸和运动物理治疗方案的联合应用中获益,心脏手术前后身体功能活动恢复更快。具体而言,运动方案与心脏手术前后更大的跑步自主性相关。