Sherbrooke University, 4-309 Rue Jacques cartier Est, Chicoutimi, Québec, Canada
Project "Evacuation of mothers in five districts of Kayes" MEDIK, Mali
Rural Remote Health. 2020 Jul;20(3):5772. doi: 10.22605/RRH5772. Epub 2020 Jul 31.
Shortage of health workers is a worldwide problem but is particularly critical in sub-Saharan Africa. In Mali, the number of health workers is insufficient and their retention is low, particularly in rural and remote areas. Rural postings are unattractive to health workers. Very few studies have examined the factors contributing to the shortage and poor retention of health workers in Mali. The objective of this study is to identify and understand these factors with regards to skilled health workers in two rural health districts (Yélimané and Bafoulabé) in the region of Kayes, Mali.
This qualitative study is based on the conceptual framework of Lehman, Dieleman and Martineau. Data were collected through 46 in-depth interviews with health workers and decision-makers. A thematic content analysis was conducted with the support of QDA Miner software.
The study identified factors contributing to the insufficient allocation and poor retention of rural health workers in these districts. They are individual-level factors (gender, family situation, age), unattractive living and working conditions, community recognition and participation, quality of leadership, an unfavourable recruitment/assignment process and insufficient financial incentives. It shows that female staff have specific constraints that prevent them from deploying to or staying in rural areas for long periods. In addition, the number of staff recruited at the national level is unpredictable and insufficient, while their recruitment and assignment process is perceived to be inequitable and not very transparent, disadvantaging rural health structures. Some strategies were identified to improve the availability and retention of health workers in these areas. They take into account certain social norms, notably gender roles, and include the improvement of living and working conditions, as well as the strengthening of health workforce management.
This study's findings highlight the multifaceted nature of factors contributing to the availability and retention of health workers in rural and remote areas of sub-Saharan Africa and the challenges associated with them. This study identifies some strategies that can be combined to facilitate the retention and availability of health workers in these areas. Some strategies involve actors outside the health sector, requiring joint efforts for their implementation. This research provides decision-makers with evidence to support informed decision making with regards to the retention of health workers in rural areas.
卫生工作者短缺是一个全球性问题,但在撒哈拉以南非洲尤为严重。在马里,卫生工作者人数不足,留用率低,尤其是在农村和偏远地区。农村岗位对卫生工作者没有吸引力。很少有研究调查马里卫生工作者短缺和留用率低的原因。本研究的目的是确定并了解在马里两个农村卫生区(耶利曼内和巴福拉贝)的熟练卫生工作者方面造成这种情况的因素。
这是一项基于 Lehman、Dieleman 和 Martineau 概念框架的定性研究。通过对卫生工作者和决策者进行 46 次深入访谈收集数据。在 QDA Miner 软件的支持下进行了主题内容分析。
研究确定了导致这些地区农村卫生工作者分配不足和留用率低的因素。这些因素包括个人层面的因素(性别、家庭状况、年龄)、缺乏吸引力的生活和工作条件、社区认可和参与、领导力质量、不利的招聘/分配过程以及缺乏足够的经济激励。研究表明,女性员工有特定的限制,使她们无法长期部署到农村地区或留在农村地区。此外,国家一级招聘的工作人员数量不可预测且不足,而他们的招聘和分配过程被认为不公平且不透明,使农村卫生结构处于不利地位。为了改善这些地区卫生工作者的可用性和留用率,确定了一些策略。这些策略考虑到了某些社会规范,特别是性别角色,并包括改善生活和工作条件,以及加强卫生人力管理。
本研究结果突出了导致撒哈拉以南非洲农村和偏远地区卫生工作者的可用性和留用率的因素的多面性,以及与之相关的挑战。本研究确定了一些可以结合使用的策略,以促进这些地区卫生工作者的留用和可用性。其中一些策略涉及卫生部门以外的行为者,需要共同努力加以实施。本研究为决策者提供了证据,以便在农村地区卫生工作者留用方面做出明智的决策。