Amado Isabelle, Moualla Mona, Jouve Julia, Brénugat-Herné Lindsay, Attali David, Willard Dominique, Rigaut Bérangère, Malangin Brigitte, Kern Laurence, Meyniel Clementine, Gaillard Raphaël, Plaze Marion, Perquier Florence, Yannick Morvan
Groupe Hospitalier Universitaire Paris Psychiatrie et Neurosciences, Sainte Anne Hospital, Paris, France.
Psychiatry and Neuroscience Center, National Resource Center for Cognitive Remediation and Psychosocial Rehabilitation (C3RP), Paris, France.
Front Psychiatry. 2020 Jul 3;11:609. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2020.00609. eCollection 2020.
Employment rate in psychiatry is around 10 to 30%. Cognitive remediation (CR) associated with psychosocial rehabilitation shows good functional outcomes, with a high level of satisfaction in participants provided by tailored CR. However, few studies looked at the long-term outcome in participants who experienced such a program. This retrospective survey examines the outcome of persons having psychiatric diseases 2 to 9 years after being treated with a personalized CR program. The survey included 12 domains with questions relevant to work, studies, before CR (T1) and at the moment of the survey (T2), questions about housing, relatedness, familiar relationships and daily activities at T2. Finally, a narrative interview was included to express feelings of the participants about CR. Sixty-six participants completed the survey, and were treated with neurocognitive or social cognition programs. Their diagnosis was: schizophrenia (80.3%), neurodevelopment disorder (autism as well as genetic or metabolic disease with psychiatric expression) (15.2%) and bipolar disorder (4.5%). The comparison between T1 and T2 showed significant difference for job employment (P < 0.001), even for competitive jobs (p < 0.007), for performing studies (p = 0.033), for practicing a physical activity (0.033) or reading (0.002). Outcome was also examined in reference to the delay from CR to highlight changes in patient characteristics and service delivery over the years. Hence, the total sample was split in two subgroups: CR delivered in 2009-2013 (n = 37); CR delivered in 2014-2016 (n = 29). While in the former group more participants were working (p = 0.037), in the latter group, which was younger (p = 0.04), more participants were studying (p = 0.02). At T2, a majority of persons experienced no relapse, three years (79.1%) to 8 years (56.8%) after CR, when referring to the anamnesis. Concerning subjective perception of CR, participants expressed feelings concerning positive impact on clarity of thought, on cognitive functions, self-confidence, perceiving CR as an efficient help for work and studies. To conclude, even long years after a personalized CR program, good benefits in terms of employment or studies emerge when compared to the status before CR, with good determinants for recovery in terms of leisure or physical activity practice.
精神病学领域的就业率约为10%至30%。与心理社会康复相关的认知康复(CR)显示出良好的功能结果,量身定制的CR使参与者满意度很高。然而,很少有研究关注经历过此类项目的参与者的长期结果。这项回顾性调查考察了接受个性化CR项目治疗2至9年后患有精神疾病者的结果。该调查包括12个领域,有关于工作、学习在CR之前(T1)和调查时(T2)的相关问题,以及关于T2时住房、人际关系、家庭关系和日常活动的问题。最后,纳入了一次叙述性访谈以表达参与者对CR的感受。66名参与者完成了调查,他们接受了神经认知或社会认知项目治疗。他们的诊断为:精神分裂症(80.3%)、神经发育障碍(自闭症以及有精神症状的遗传或代谢疾病)(15.2%)和双相情感障碍(4.5%)。T1和T2之间的比较显示,在就业(P < 0.001)方面有显著差异,甚至在竞争性工作方面(p < 0.007)、在进行学业方面(p = 0.033)、在进行体育活动(0.033)或阅读(0.002)方面也有显著差异。还参照从CR开始后的时间间隔来考察结果,以突出多年来患者特征和服务提供方面的变化。因此,总样本被分为两个亚组:2009 - 2013年接受CR治疗的(n = 37);2014 - 2016年接受CR治疗的(n = 29)。在前一组中,更多参与者在工作(p = 0.037),而在后一组中,该组更年轻(p = 0.04),更多参与者在学习(p = 0.02)。在T2时,根据病历记录,大多数人在CR后3年(79.1%)至8年(56.8%)没有复发。关于对CR的主观感受,参与者表达了CR对思维清晰度、认知功能、自信心有积极影响的感受,认为CR对工作和学习是一种有效的帮助。总之,即使在个性化CR项目实施多年后,与CR之前的状态相比,在就业或学习方面仍出现了良好的效益,在休闲或体育活动方面也有恢复的良好因素。